[Sigia-l] People thinking like computers (was ROI/Value of Search Engine...)

Boniface Lau boniface_lau at compuserve.com
Sun Feb 9 20:44:01 EST 2003


> From: sigia-l-admin at asis.org [mailto:sigia-l-admin at asis.org]On
> Behalf Of Christopher Fahey [askrom]
[...]
> Let's take Jared's first example:
> 
> > (1) A user, looking for "a low-cost, yet reliable laptop computer
> > that will last 4 years for his son who is going away to school"
> > typed "laptops" into Amazon's search and receives 210 results, for
> > which he has no way of discerning if any of these computers match
> > his criteria.
> 
> I'll confess that my first reaction to this was to roll my eyes at
> this person's deep misunderstanding of how search engines work. But
> then I wondered: why exactly did this person type in "laptops"
> instead of something more specific like "low cost reliable laptops"

May be because the user recognized that "low cost reliable" are
terms too vague to use?


> or even "I am looking for a low-cost, yet reliable laptop computer
> that will last 4 years for my son who is going away to school"?

I would expect the above query from people who have very little
exposure to computers.


> I mean, s/he wouldn't walk up to a salesperson at CompUSA and simply
> say "laptops" and expect to find a useful recommendation either.

Wait a minute... you expect web users to interact with a web page like
they would with a salesperson?


> Why did this person only type one word?

Probably because the user had heard that search engines work on
keywords.


[...]
> The fact that this user just doesn't know the right way to use a
> search engine

Entering "laptops" is the wrong way to use a search engine to search
for laptops?

Mind you, most of today's search engines are keyword-based. Thus,
entering keywords is the common sense way to use a search engine
unless indicated otherwise by the search engine documentation.


Boniface



More information about the Sigia-l mailing list