Gingras, Y (Gingras, Yves) The collective construction of scientific memory: The Einstein-Poincare connection and its discontents, 1905-2005 HISTORY OF SCIENCE, 46 (151): 75-114 Part 1 MAR 2008

[Eugene Garfield]

Email Address: gingras.yves at uqam.ca

Author(s): Gingras, Y (Gingras, Yves) 

Title: The collective construction of scientific memory: The Einstein-
Poincare connection and its discontents, 1905-2005 

Source: HISTORY OF SCIENCE, 46 (151): 75-114 Part 1 MAR 2008 

Language: English 

Document Type: Review 

Keywords Plus: SPECIAL RELATIVITY; RENDICONTI PAPER; PRIORITY DISPUTE; 
BELATED DECISION; LORENTZ; TRANSFORMATIONS; DISCOVERY; PRINCIPLE; 
CITATION; PHYSICS 

Addresses: Univ Quebec Montreal, Montreal, PQ, Canada 

Reprint Address: Gingras, Y, Univ Quebec Montreal, Montreal, PQ, Canada. 

Cited Reference Count: 136 

Times Cited: 0 

Publisher: SCIENCE HISTORY PUBLICATIONS LTD 

Publisher Address: 16 RUTHERFORD RD, CAMBRIDGE CB2 2HH, ENGLAND 

ISSN: 0073-2753 

29-char Source Abbrev.: HIST SCI 

ISO Source Abbrev.: Hist. Sci. 

Source Item Page Count: 40 

Subject Category: History & Philosophy Of Science
 
ISI Document Delivery No.: 269QU 

HIMMEL ERDE 28 : 97 1910 

ABIR PG
COMMEMORATIVE PRACTI : 1999 

ABIR PG
MISE MEMOIRE SCI ETH : 1998 

APPEL P
H POINCARE : 86 1925 

AZOUVI F
DESCARTES FRANCE : 2002 

GEN RELATIVITY PAPER : 21 1972 

BERGMANN PG
SCIENCE 123 : 488 1956 

BEYERCHEN AD
SCI HITLER POLITICS : 90 1977 

BEYLER RH
A EINSTEIN CHIEF ENG : 322 2005 

BIEZUNSKI M
EINSTEIN PARIS : 16 1991 

BLUMENTHAL O
RELATIVITATSPRINZIP : 1913 

BORN M
BORN EINSTEIN LETT : 32 2005 

BORN M
BRIT J PHILOS SCI 5 : 262 1954
 
BORN M
J PHYS 56 : 114 1988 

BOURDIEU P
ACTES RECHERCHE SCI 106 : 117 1995 

BOURDIEU P
SCI SCI REFLEXIVITY : 2004 

BRANNIGAN A
SOCIAL BASIS SCI DIS : 1981 

BRIDGMAN PC
ISIS 47 : 429 1956 

CASSIDY DC
HIST STUD PHYS SCI 16 : 177 1986 

CERF R
Dismissing renewed attempts to deny Einstein the discovery of special 
relativity 
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS 74 : 818 DOI 10.1119/1.2221341 2006 

CERF R
ISIS 98 : 366 2007 

CLARK JT
CRITICAL PROBLEMS HI : 103 1959 

CORRY L
Belated decision in the Hilbert-Einstein priority dispute 
SCIENCE 278 : 1270 1997 

CRAWFORD E
BEGINNINGS NOBEL I S : 101 1987 

CRAWFORD JL
NOBEL POPULATION 190 : 52 1987 

CRELINSTEIN J
EINSTEINS JURY RACE : 31 2006 

CUNNINGHAM E
PRINCIPLE RELATIVITY : 173 1914 

CUVAJ C
NOTE ON POINCARE AND RELATIVITY 
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS 38 : 774 1970 

CUVAJ C
HENRI POINCARES MATHEMATICAL CONTRIBUTIONS TO RELATIVITY AND POINCARE 
STRESSES 
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS 36 : 1102 1968 

CUVAJ C
JAPANESE STUDIES HIS 10 : 113 1971 

DARRIGOL O
THE ELECTRON THEORIES OF LARMOR AND LORENTZ - A COMPARATIVE-STUDY 
HISTORICAL STUDIES IN THE PHYSICAL AND BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES 24 : 265 1994 

DARRIGOL O
HSPS 26 : 312 1996 

DARRIGOL O
The mystery of the Einstein-Poincare connection 
ISIS 95 : 614 2004 

DARRIGOL O
STUD HIST PHILOS M P 26 : 1 1995 

DASSAULT D
LIVRE CENTENAIRE NAI : 101 1955 

DAVIS NZ
MEMORY AND COUNTER-MEMORY - INTRODUCTION 
REPRESENTATIONS 26 : 1 1989 

DEBROGLIE L
SAVANTS DECOUVERTES : 51 1956 

DELAPORTE F
VITAL RATIONALIST SE : 51 1994 

DINGLE H
BRIT J PHILOS SCI 16 : 244 1965 

EARMAN J
P BIENN M PHIL SCI A : 403 1982 

EDGE D
HIST SCI 17 : 102 1979 

EINSTEIN
COLLECTED PAPERS A E : 1987 

EINSTEIN
COMMUNICATION 0721 : 1920 

ELTON L
EINSTEIN, GENERAL-RELATIVITY, AND THE GERMAN PRESS, 1919-1920 
ISIS 77 : 95 1986 

ELZINGA A
EINSTEINS NOBEL PRIZ : 2006 

FLOOD C
J EUR STUD 35 : 222 2005 

FREEMAN LC
CENTRALITY IN SOCIAL NETWORKS CONCEPTUAL CLARIFICATION 
SOCIAL NETWORKS 1 : 215 1979 

GALISON P
ISIS 95 : 611 2004 

GENOVESI A
CARTEGGIO A EINSTEIN 10 : R43 2000 

GIANNONI C
P BIENN M PHIL SCI A : 575 1970 

GINGRAS Y
P ISSI 2007 11 INT C : 314 2007 

GINGRAS Y
POSITIONING HIST SCI : 61 2007 

GMUR M
Co-citation analysis and the search for invisible colleges: A 
methodological evaluation 
SCIENTOMETRICS 57 : 27 2003 

GOENNER H
SCI CONTEXT 6 : 107 1993 

GOENNER HFM
STUDIES HIST GEN REL : 15 1993 

GOLDBERG S
POINCARE,H AND EINSTEINS THEORY OF RELATIVITY 
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS 35 : 934 1967 

GRAHAM L
FUNCTIONS USES DISCI : R9 1983 

GRUNBAUM A
J PHILOS 59 : 573 1962 

GUTTING G
EINSTEINS DISCOVERY OF SPECIAL RELATIVITY 
PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE 39 : 51 1972 

HIROSIGE T
HIST STUD PHYS BIOL 1 : 151 1969 

HOLTON G
AM J PHYS 28 : 627 1960 

HOLTON G
THEMATIC ORIGINS SCI : 234 1973 

ILIFFE R
HIST SCI 30 : 30 1992 

ILLY J
STUD HIST PHILOS M P 12 : 173 1981 

IVES HE
EINSTEIN MYTH IVES P : 1980 

IVES HE
P AM PHILOS SOC 95 : 125 1951 

JANSSEN M
PHYS PERSPECTIVE 4 : 428 2002 

JUNGNICKEL C
INTELLECTUAL MASTERY 2 : 248 1986 

KAHAN T
REV HIST SCI LEURS A 12 : 164 1959 

KATZIR S
Poincare's relativistic physics: Its origins and nature 
PHYSICS IN PERSPECTIVE 7 : 268 DOI 10.1007/s00016-004-0234-y 2005 

KESWANI GH
INTIMATIONS OF RELATIVITY RELATIVITY BEFORE EINSTEIN 
BRITISH JOURNAL FOR THE PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE 34 : 343 1983 

KESWANI GH
BRIT J PHILOS SCI 17 : 150 1966 

KESWANI GH
ORIGIN AND CONCEPT OF RELATIVITY .1. 
BRITISH JOURNAL FOR THE PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE 15 : 286 1965 

KILMISTER CW
SPECIAL THEORY RELAT : 1970 

KIRCHERBERGER HP
THEORIE RELATIVITE E : 1922 

KITTEL C
LARMOR AND PREHISTORY OF LORENTZ TRANSFORMATIONS 
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS 42 : 726 1974 

KLEIN
WISSENSCHAFTLICHER B : 27 1979 

LANGEVIN P
B SOC FRANCAISE PHYS 119 : 15 1999 

LANGEVIN P
REV METAPHYSIQUE M S 5 : 699 1913 

LEBON
OEUVRES CHOISIES 4 : 186 1989 

LEBON G
The relativity principle and inter-atonic energy. 
COMPTES RENDUS HEBDOMADAIRES DES SEANCES DE L ACADEMIE DES SCIENCES 159 : 
26 1914 

LEFFLER GM
OEUVRES H POINCARE 9 : 7 1954 

LEON X
B SOC FRANCAISE PHIL 17 : 93 1922 

LEVEUGLE J
JAUNE ROUGE APR : 49 1994 

LEVEUGLE J
RELATIVITE POINCARE : 2004 

LEYDESDORFF L
Theories of citation? 
SCIENTOMETRICS 43 : 5 1998 

LORENTZ HA
Two memories about Henri Poincare on mathematical physics. 
ACTA MATHEMATICA 38 : 293 1921 

LORENTZ HA
ASTROPHYS J 58 : 350 1928 

LORENTZ HA
PROBLEMS MODERN PHYS : 127 1927 

LORENTZ HA
THEORY ELECT : 213 1952 

MACROSSAN MN
A NOTE ON RELATIVITY BEFORE EINSTEIN 
BRITISH JOURNAL FOR THE PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE 37 : 232 1986 

MARPEAU B
GUSTAVE BON PARCOURS : 250 2000 

MERTON RK
SOC SCI THEORETICAL : 301 1973 

MILLER AI
A EINSTEINS SPECIAL : 336 1981 

MILLER AI
COMMENT ON - POINCARES RENDICONTI PAPER ON RELATIVITY .1. 
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS 40 : 923 1972 

MILLER AI
ARCH INT HIST SCI 37 : 95 1987 

MILLER AI
H POINCARE SCI PHILO : 69 1994 

MISSNER M
WHY EINSTEIN BECAME FAMOUS IN AMERICA 
SOCIAL STUDIES OF SCIENCE 15 : 267 1985 

MITTAGLEFFLER G
COMMUNICATION 1216 : 1919 

NERSESSIAN NJ
WHY WASNT LORENTZ EINSTEIN - AN EXAMINATION OF THE SCIENTIFIC METHOD OF 
LORENTZ,H.A. 
CENTAURUS 29 : 205 1986 

NORDMANN C
MATIN 0323 : 1922 

NYE MJ
HIST STUDIES PHYS SC 4 : 191 1974 

PATY M
COMP RECEPTION RELAT : 119 1987 

PATY M
EPISTEMOLOGIQUES 2 : 33 2002 

PAULI W
THEORY RELATIVITY : 2 1958 

PILE G
JAUNE ROUGE APR : 29 1994 

POINCARE H
MECANIQUE NOUVELLE C : 19 1924 

POINCARE H
NEUE MECHANIK : 1911 

POPPER KR
BRIT J PHILOS SCI 16 : 332 1966 

PROVOST JP
Poincare relativity of 1905 and active transformations. 
ARCHIVE FOR HISTORY OF EXACT SCIENCES 60 : 337 DOI 10.1007/s00407-005-0104-
2 2006 

RINDLER W
EINSTEINS PRIORITY IN RECOGNIZING TIME DILATION PHYSICALLY 
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS 38 : 1111 1970 

SAUER T
ARCH HIST EXACT SCI 59 : 557 2005 

SCHWARTZ HM
POINCARES RENDICONTI PAPER ON RELATIVITY .1. 
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS 39 : 1287 1971 

SCHWARTZ HMJ
A NOTE ON POINCARES CONTRIBUTION TO RELATIVITY 
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS 33 : 170 1965 

SCOTT W
EXPANDING WORLDS GEN : 45 1999 

SCRIBNER C
HENRI POINCARE + PRINCIPLE OF RELATIVITY 
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS 32 : 672 1964 

SMALL H
STRUCTURE OF SCIENTIFIC LITERATURES .1. IDENTIFYING AND GRAPHING 
SPECIALTIES 
SCIENCE STUDIES 4 : 17 1974 

SMALL HG
CITED DOCUMENTS AS CONCEPT SYMBOLS 
SOCIAL STUDIES OF SCIENCE 8 : 327 1978 

SMALL HG
CO-CITATION MODEL OF A SCIENTIFIC SPECIALTY - LONGITUDINAL-STUDY OF 
COLLAGEN RESEARCH 
SOCIAL STUDIES OF SCIENCE 7 : 139 1977 

SOMMERFELD A
SCIENCE 39 : 944 1914 

SPONSEL A
Constructing a 'revolution in science': the campaign to promote a 
favourable reception for the 1919 solar eclipse experiments 
BRITISH JOURNAL FOR THE HISTORY OF SCIENCE 35 : 439 2002 

STACHEL J
New light on the Einstein-Hilbert priority question 
JOURNAL OF ASTROPHYSICS AND ASTRONOMY 20 : 91 1999 

STALEY R
On the histories of relativity - The propagation and elaboration of 
relativity theory in participant histories in Germany, 1905-1911 
ISIS 89 : 263 1998 

STALEY R
ISIS 89 : 277 1988 

THOMINE P
TOUT EST RELATIF M P : 2005 

VOLTERRA V
LECT CELEBRATION 20 : 13 1912 

WARWICK A
MASTERS THEORY CAMBR : 402 2003 

WASSERMAN S
SOCIAL NETWORKS ANAL : 1994 

WAZECK M
EINSTEIN DAILY PRESS : 67 2004 

WHITROW GJ
BRIT J PHILOS SCI 7 : 180 1956 

WHITTAKER E
BIOGRAPHICAL MEMOIRS 1 : 42 1955 

WHITTAKER ET
HIST THEORIES AETHER : 1953 

WIEN W
ACTA MATH 38 : 290 1921 

WINTERBERG F
On "Belated decision in the Hilbert-Einstein priority dispute", published 
by L. Corry, J. Renn, and J. Stachel 
ZEITSCHRIFT FUR NATURFORSCHUNG SECTION A-A JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL SCIENCES 
59 : 715 2004 

ZAHAR E
BRIT J PHILOS SCI 29 : 49 1978 

ZAHAR E
EINSTEINS REVOLUTION : CH5 1989