ABS:

Mon Feb 21 18:23:20 EST 2000

Notes: Author's email address is donohue at darla.badm.sc.edu

============================================================
FN ISI Export Format
VR 1.0
PT J
AU Donohue, JM
   Fox, JB
TI A multi-method evaluation of journals in the decision and
   management sciences by US academics
SO OMEGA-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT SCIENCE
NR 92
C1 Univ S Carolina, Dept Management Sci, Columbia, SC 29208 USA.
   Univ S Carolina, Dept Management Sci, Columbia, SC 29208 USA.
   Appalachian State Univ, Walker Coll Business, Dept Management, Boone, NC 28608 USA.
DE journal quality; citation analysis; business and management
   studies
ID INSTITUTIONAL RESEARCH PRODUCTIVITY; ALTERNATIVE RATING SYSTEM;
   CITATION ANALYSIS; ECONOMICS JOURNALS; MIS RESEARCH; RELATIVE
   QUALITY; PSYCHOLOGY JOURNALS; FINANCIAL RESEARCH; FLAGSHIP
   JOURNALS; BUSINESS
AB Numerous studies published in the academic literature address
   the issue of journal quality. However, little has been done to
   evaluate the broad set of journals pertinent to academic
   research in the decision and management sciences. This study
   examines the quality of such journals from a US point of view
   using both survey- and citation-based measures of journal
   quality. The survey-based measure is the perceived quality
   ratings assigned by US academics in the management science
   field. The citation-based measure is the impact factor, an
   indication of how often the articles in a journal are cited.
   This study finds that perceived quality ratings of the journals
   are positively correlated with citation impact factors. Also,
   both of these quality measures are found to be positively
   correlated with journal circulation and negatively correlated
   with acceptance rate. Journal quality ratings appear to vary
   across reviewers with different research interest areas and
   reviewers seem to rate journals higher if they have published
   in them. (C) 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
CR 1996, SERIALS DIRECTORY IN
   *I SCI INF, 1996, SCI CIT IND
   *I SCI INF, 1996, SOC SCI CIT IND
   AMOAKOGYAMPATH K, 1989, J OPERATIONS MANAGEM, V8, P250
   ANDREWS WT, 1978, ACCOUNT REV, V53, P135
   BARMAN S, 1991, J OPERATIONS MANAGEM, V10, P194
   BARNETT V, 1974, OUTLIERS STAT DATA
   BEATTIE VA, 1989, BR ACCOUNT REV, V21, P267
   BEILOCK RP, 1986, AM J AGR ECON, V68, P595
   BILLINGS BB, 1972, WESTERN ECON J, V10, P467
   BLALOCK HM, 1974, MEASUREMENT SOCIAL S
   BRINN T, 1996, ACCOUNT BUSINESS RES, V26, P265
   BROAD WJ, 1981, SCIENCE, V211, P1137
   BROWN LD, 1994, CONT ACCOUNT RES, V11, P223
   BROWN LD, 1985, J ACCOUNTING RES, V23, P84
   BUFFA ES, 1980, J OPERATIONS MANAGEM, V1, P8
   BUSH WC, 1974, REV ECON STAT, V56, P123
   CABELL DWE, 1994, CABELLS DIRECTORY PU
   CARR H, 1991, J SYST MANAGE, V42, P37
   CARR HH, 1991, J SYST MANAGE, V42, P18
   CHASE RB, 1980, J OPERATIONS MANAGEM, V1, P1
   COE R, 1984, ACAD MANAGE J, V27, P660
   COE RK, 1983, J FINANCIAL RES, V6, P345
   COE RK, 1983, J MARKETING ED, V5, P37
   CULNAN MJ, 1987, MIS QUART, V11, P341
   DIAMOND AM, 1986, J HUMAN RESOURCES, V21, P201
   DIAMOND AM, 1985, SCIENTOMETRICS, V8, P815
   DOKE ER, 1987, J COMPUT INFORM SYST, V27, P30
   DOYLE JR, 1995, OMEGA, V33, P257
   DOYLE JR, 1996, OMEGA-INT J MANAGE S, V24, P13
   DOYLE JR, 1996, OMEGA-INT J MANAGE S, V24, P603
   DYCKMAN TR, 1984, J ACCOUNTING RES, V22, P225
   EDERINGTON LH, 1979, J FINANC, V34, P777
   EOM SB, 1995, OMEGA-INT J MANAGE S, V23, P511
   EXTEJT MM, 1990, J MANAGE, V16, P539
   FEINGOLD A, 1989, AM PSYCHOL, V36, P961
   FERGUSON W, 1983, TRANSPORT J, V23, P69
   GARFIELD E, 1972, SCIENCE, V178, P471
   GILLENSON ML, 1991, MIS QUART, V15, P447
   GOH CH, 1996, OMEGA-INT J MANAGE S, V24, P337
   GROVER V, 1992, DATA BASE, V23, P5
   GUPTA UG, 1997, INTERFACES, V27, P85
   HAMILTON S, 1983, DATA BASE, V14, P3
   HAWKINS RG, 1973, J POLIT ECON, V81, P1017
   HOLSAPPLE CW, 1994, OMEGA-INT J MANAGE S, V22, P69
   HOWARD TP, 1983, ACCOUNT REV, V58, P765
   HOWARD TP, 1981, ACCOUNT REV, V56, P613
   JONES MJ, 1996, OMEGA-INT J MANAGE S, V24, P597
   JONES MJ, 1996, OMEGA-INT J MANAGE S, V24, P607
   KAWASAKI JL, 1995, J EXTENSION, V33
   KIESLER S, 1986, PUBLIC OPIN QUART, V50, P402
   KLEMKOSKY RC, 1977, J FINANC, V32, P901
   KOONG KS, 1989, J COMPUTER INFORMATO, V29, P1
   KOULACK D, 1975, AM PSYCHOL, V30, P1049
   LENDING D, 1992, DATA BASE, V23, P5
   LIEBOWITZ SJ, 1984, J ECON LIT, V22, P77
   LODGE M, 1981, MAGNITUDE SCALING QU
   LUKE RH, 1987, J ACADEMY MARKETING, V15, P74
   MACMILLAN IC, 1987, STRATEGIC MANAGE J, V8, P183
   MALHOTRA MK, 1996, J OPERATINS MANAGEME, V14, P55
   MEDOFF MH, 1989, J ECON EDUC, V20, P405
   MILLER T, 1979, IMPROVING COLLEGE U, V27, P102
   MITCHELL G, 1996, OMEGA-INT J MANAGE S, V24, P613
   MOORE LJ, 1980, Q REV ECON BUS, V20, P87
   MOORE WJ, 1972, WESTERN ECON J, V10, P156
   MORRISON J, 1995, COMMUN ACM, V38, P80
   NIEMI AW, 1987, J FINANC, V42, P1389
   NIEMI AW, 1988, REV BUS ECON RES, V23, P1
   NORD JH, 1995, INFORM MANAGE, V29, P29
   OMAR MH, 1991, INTERFACE, V13, P18
   ORMEROD R, 1997, OPER RES, V45, P178
   ORMEROD RJ, 1997, OMEGA-INT J MANAGE S, V25, P599
   OUTREVILLE JF, 1985, J RISK INSUR, V52, P721
   PETRY G, 1988, Q REV ECON BUS, V28, P88
   REISMAN A, 1988, IEEE T ENG MANAGE, V35, P215
   REISMAN A, 1995, OPER RES, V43, P731
   ROSENFELD P, 1993, AM BEHAV SCI, V36, P485
   ROTHKOPF MH, 1996, INTERFACES, V26, P16
   ROTTON J, 1993, AM PSYCHOL, V40, P911
   SALADIN B, 1985, OM REV, V3, P3
   SHARPLIN AD, 1985, HUM RELAT, V38, P139
   SKEELS JW, 1972, WESTERN ECON J, V10, P470
   SPROULL LS, 1986, ACAD MANAGE J, V29, P159
   STAHL MJ, 1988, ACAD MANAGE J, V31, P707
   STAUDTE RG, 1990, ROBUST ESTIMATION TE
   THACH L, 1995, EDUC TECHNOL, V35, P27
   VELLENGA DB, 1981, TRANSPORT J, V21, P44
   WALSTROM KA, 1995, COMMUN ACM, V38, P93
   WEBER RP, 1981, ACCOUNT REV, V56, P596
   WHITE MJ, 1977, AM PSYCHOL, V32, P301
   WILLAIMS WW, 1987, Q REV ECON BUS, V27, P77
   YOUNG S, 1996, J OPERATIONS MANAGEM, V14, P41
BP 17
EP 36
PG 20
JI Omega-Int. J. Manage. Sci.
PY 2000
PD FEB
VL 28
IS 1
GA 269GX
RP Donohue JM
   Univ S Carolina, Dept Management Sci, Columbia, SC 29208 USA.
J9 OMEGA-INT J MANAGE SCI
UT ISI:000084469300002
ER

---------------------------

c. ISI, reprinted with permission

Please visit their website at www.isinet.com