[Sigia-l] Useful tools

Listera listera at rcn.com
Wed Jul 16 20:49:46 EDT 2003


"Andrew Knott" wrote:

> I think it's almost essential that Objects be understood. It's not
> really that complicated.

Creating efficient objects /is/ quite difficult and usually a vector of
experience/time.

> UML is often used by developers and UI  designers for their documentation,

I'm against IAs using UML to indicate functionality to developers. As a
developer I wouldn't want my objects and schemas defined by an IA. As an IA
I don't want to spend an inordinate amount of time and energy to do
something that's best left in the domain of developers. I haven't seen too
many IAs who are either interested in or capable of generating UML that's
worth much. The best thing an IA can do for the developer is to create a
functional prototype that demonstrates without ambiguity the functionality
desired. It's then the developer's job to realize that in code, in whatever
language/paradigm they feel comfortable in.

> it's not hard for IA's to work with  this as well.

I doubt there are more than a handful IAs here who would be comfortable
doing that.

> They don't have to get into the nitty gritty of OOP to
> see how everything works.

That's a very difficult line to draw, like being a little pregnant.

I'll take a prototype over UML any day.

Ziya
Nullius in Verba 





More information about the Sigia-l mailing list