[Asis-standards] 2 more votes

[Mark Needleman]

Marcia

Thanks. How do you suggest we vote on the ISBN WG disbanding?

Mark

Sent from Mark Needleman’s iPhone

Albert Einstein “There are two things that are infinite. The Universe and human stupidity. And I’m not certain about  the Universe”

Albert Einstein “ The difference between genius and stupidity is that genius has limits”

> On Jan 11, 2018, at 12:52 PM, ZENG, MARCIA <mzeng at kent.edu> wrote:
> 
> Mark,
> Me too, kind of worried about ISBN. Does this mean no more persistent efforts on ISBN and will just let it go? That will be a big impact. It might not look like another revision is needed soon but the duty is always there. Unless there is a clear take over by another group, I do not think it should be just let go.
> 
> For the TC46/SC9 Working Group 12, Indexes and Indexing, it will be good to have a convenor, of course. Drahomira Cupar seemed to be active in the field of knowledge organization.
> 
> Marcia
> 
> From: Asis-standards <asis-standards-bounces at asist.org> on behalf of Mark Needleman <needleman_mark at yahoo.com>
> Sent: Wednesday, January 10, 2018 2:04:50 PM
> To: ASIST Standards Committee
> Subject: [Asis-standards] 2 more votes
>  
> 2 more votes coming up by the  end of January
> 
> 1)SHORT-TERM BALLOT - Approval of SC9/WG12 Convenor
> 
> Do you approve of the appointment of Drahomira Cupar as WG12 Convenor?
> 
> TC46/SC9 Working Group 12, Indexes and Indexing has been without a convenor. Drahomira Cupar, PhD, University of Zadar, Croatia has expressed interest in becoming the next convenor.
> 
> Do you approve of the appointment of Drahomira Cupar as the TC46/SC9 Working Group 12 convenor?
> 
> DUE 1/30/2018
> 
> 2) SHORT-TERM BALLOT - Disbanding of SC9/WG4
> 
> 
> 
> Do you approve of the resolution disbanding SC9/WG4 ISBN?
> Resolution proposed to disband SC9/WG4:
> 
> ISO/TC46/SC9 resolves to disband its Working Group (WG) 4, International Standard Book Numbering (ISBN) with the publication of ISO 2108, Information and documentation – International Standard Book Number (ISBN) and expresses its appreciation to Ms. Stella Griffiths for her expert leadership of its WG4 and the publication of ISO 2108. 
> 
> Do you approve the disbanding of SC9/WG4, International Standard Book Numbering (ISBN)?
> 
> PERSONAL OPINION - The rationale for this is the work on the ISBN has been completed so this working group is no longer needed - Im not sure I agree with that
> 
> DUE 1/30/2018
> 
> Relevant documents attached
> 
> Mark
> 
-------------- next part --------------

   Marcia

   Thanks. How do you suggest we vote on the ISBN WG disbanding?

   Mark
   Sent from Mark Needleman’s iPhone
   Albert Einstein “There are two things that are infinite. The Universe and
   human stupidity. And I’m not certain about  the Universe”
   Albert Einstein “ The difference between genius and stupidity is that genius
   has limits”
   On Jan 11, 2018, at 12:52 PM, ZENG, MARCIA <[1]mzeng at kent.edu> wrote:

   Mark,

   Me  too, kind of worried about ISBN. Does this mean no more persistent
   efforts on ISBN and will just let it go? That will be a big impact. It might
   not look like another revision is needed soon but the duty is always there.
   Unless there is a clear take over by another group, I do not think it should
   be just let go.

   For the TC46/SC9 Working Group 12, Indexes and Indexing, it will be good to
   have a convenor, of course. Drahomira Cupar seemed to be active in the field
   of knowledge organization.

   Marcia
       ______________________________________________________________

   From: Asis-standards <[2]asis-standards-bounces at asist.org> on behalf of Mark
   Needleman <[3]needleman_mark at yahoo.com>
   Sent: Wednesday, January 10, 2018 2:04:50 PM
   To: ASIST Standards Committee
   Subject: [Asis-standards] 2 more votes

   2 more votes coming up by the  end of January
   1)SHORT-TERM BALLOT - Approval of SC9/WG12 Convenor
   Do you approve of the appointment of Drahomira Cupar as WG12 Convenor?
   TC46/SC9 Working Group 12, Indexes and Indexing has been without a convenor.
   Drahomira Cupar, PhD, University of Zadar, Croatia has expressed interest in
   becoming the next convenor.
   Do you approve of the appointment of Drahomira Cupar as the TC46/SC9 Working
   Group 12 convenor?
   DUE 1/30/2018
   2) SHORT-TERM BALLOT - Disbanding of SC9/WG4
   Do you approve of the resolution disbanding SC9/WG4 ISBN?
   Resolution proposed to disband SC9/WG4:
   ISO/TC46/SC9 resolves to disband its Working Group (WG) 4, International
   Standard Book Numbering (ISBN) with the publication of ISO 2108, Information
   and documentation – International Standard Book Number (ISBN) and expresses
   its appreciation to Ms. Stella Griffiths for her expert leadership of its
   WG4 and the publication of ISO 2108.
   Do  you approve the disbanding of SC9/WG4, International Standard Book
   Numbering (ISBN)?
   PERSONAL OPINION - The rationale for this is the work on the ISBN has been
   completed so this working group is no longer needed - Im not sure I agree
   with that
   DUE 1/30/2018
   Relevant documents attached
   Mark

References

   1. mailto:mzeng at kent.edu
   2. mailto:asis-standards-bounces at asist.org
   3. mailto:needleman_mark at yahoo.com