[Asis-standards] votes

[Mark Needleman]

Im not sure if this went through so Im resending it


Folks

i just cast the following votes (Tim i made one of your comments a little less strident - hope you don’t mind)

Mark

——————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————

APPROVE for Publication ISO/FDIS 15489-1 (Ed 2) Information and documentation -- Records management -- Part 1: Concepts and principles - with the following comment:

To the ASIST standards committee member  who reviewed this the metadata section seemed minimal and not of much use

Comment provided by Timothy Dickey

YES on Periodic Review: ANSI/NISO/ISO 12083-1995 (R2009), Electronic Manuscript Preparation and Markup - withdrawal of NISO version of the ISO standard

Note: This does not mean NISO is abandoning  SGML - NISO sometimes withdraws its version of ISO standards in order to avoid having to maintain the NISO standard in the event of changes to the equivalent ISO standard in order to keep the two standards in sync


Voted APPROVE for publication ISO/DIS 17068-Information and documentation - Trusted third party repository for digital records - with the following comment:

The ASIST standards committee member who reviewed the document noted that the provisions in 6.7 and 7.4 for security operations on the part of such a third-party service seem extremely minimal, considering the broad scope of the business and healthcare applications envisioned in the introduction

Comment provided by Timothy Dickey
-------------- next part --------------

   Im not sure if this went through so Im resending it

   Folks
   i just cast the following votes (Tim i made one of your comments a little
   less strident - hope you don’t mind)
   Mark
   ——————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————
   APPROVE  for  Publication  ISO/FDIS  15489-1  (Ed  2)  Information and
   documentation -- Records management -- Part 1: Concepts and principles -
   with the following comment:
   To the ASIST standards committee member  who reviewed this the metadata
   section seemed minimal and not of much use
   Comment provided by Timothy Dickey
   YES  on  Periodic Review: ANSI/NISO/ISO 12083-1995 (R2009), Electronic
   Manuscript Preparation and Markup - withdrawal of NISO version of the ISO
   standard
   Note: This does not mean NISO is abandoning  SGML - NISO sometimes withdraws
   its version of ISO standards in order to avoid having to maintain the NISO
   standard in the event of changes to the equivalent ISO standard in order to
   keep the two standards in sync
   Voted APPROVE for publication ISO/DIS 17068-Information and documentation -
   Trusted third party repository for digital records - with the following
   comment:
   The ASIST standards committee member who reviewed the document noted that
   the provisions in 6.7 and 7.4 for security operations on the part of such a
   third-party service seem extremely minimal, considering the broad scope of
   the business and healthcare applications envisioned in the introduction
   Comment provided by Timothy Dickey