[Asis-l] Quality Assurance Mechanisms for Scholarship *Before* Publication

[Gerry Mckiernan]

                   Quality Assurance Mechanisms for Scholarship *Before*
Publication 

  For a forthcoming PowerPoint article,  I am greatly interested in
learning about Any and All 
Quality Assurance Mechanisms for Scholarship *Before* Publication. The
mechanisms that come to mind at this time are:

Personal Reputation
Institutional Review
Pride
Self-Respect 
Professional Respect 
Peer Pressure
"Critical Peer Response"
Invisible College
Self-Archiving-Process-Itself
Open Access
Common Sense
Self-Correcting Dynamics

[I recognize that many of these concepts are/may be considered
synonymous, similar, and indeed overlapping.]

   An articulation of few of the mechanism can be found in the thread 

"Publication at LANL as involving peer review" in the
American-Scientist-E-PRINT-Forum
(e.g.,  http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/Hypermail/Amsci/0336.html
).

   An excellent statement of the Institutional Review concept is the
"Guild Model" articulated by 
the late ROB KLING, LISA SPECTOR, and GEOFF McKIM in the _Journal of
Electronic of Electronic Publishing_ [
http://www.press.umich.edu/jep/08-01/kling.html].

  As Always, Any and All contributions, queries, comments, critiques,
Cosmic Insights, or 'Critical Peer Responses' or Assurance Concepts are
Most Welcome!

   Regards,

/Gerry 

Gerry McKiernan
Assured Librarian
Iowa State University
Ames IA 50011

gerrymck at iastate.edu