pmd8 at CORNELL.EDU
Mon Oct 18 13:53:54 EDT 2010
Would avoiding "enemies" (i.e. competitors) provide the same result as
preferentially selecting "friends"? Many journals allow authors to list
preferential reviewers as well as those they would rather avoid
evaluating their work.
Bornmann, Lutz wrote:
> Dear Ronald,
> This could be one explanation for the better ratings of author-suggested
> reviewers. Another explanation is that the author-suggested reviewers are the
> authors' best friends. There is the danger that these reviewers rate a
> manuscript more favourably than they would rate it if it were submitted by
> unknown authors.
> I think the most important question here is: Is it fair that one group of
> reviewers rate manuscripts more favourably than another group - independently
> of the quality of the submitted manuscripts?
Philip M. Davis, Ph.D.
Department of Communication
301 Kennedy Hall
Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853
email: pmd8 at cornell.edu
phone: 607 255-2124
More information about the SIGMETRICS