Citation classics in periodontology: a controlled study by M Nien et al of Florence Italy

Fri Apr 6 16:31:57 EDT 2007

Title: Citation classics in periodontology: a controlled study 

Author(s): Nieri M
<http://apps.isiknowledge.com/WoS/CIW.cgi?SID=3C32OCP4@KPcf7gnOCk&Func=O
neClickSearch&field=AU&val=Nieri+M&ut=000244978300011&auloc=1&fullauth=%
20(Nieri,%20Michele)&curr_doc=2/1&Form=FullRecordPage&doc=2/1>  (Nieri,
Michele), Saletta D
<http://apps.isiknowledge.com/WoS/CIW.cgi?SID=3C32OCP4@KPcf7gnOCk&Func=O
neClickSearch&field=AU&val=Saletta+D&ut=000244978300011&auloc=2&fullauth
=%20(Saletta,%20Daniele)&curr_doc=2/1&Form=FullRecordPage&doc=2/1>
(Saletta, Daniele), Guidi L
<http://apps.isiknowledge.com/WoS/CIW.cgi?SID=3C32OCP4@KPcf7gnOCk&Func=O
neClickSearch&field=AU&val=Guidi+L&ut=000244978300011&auloc=3&fullauth=%
20(Guidi,%20Luisa)&curr_doc=2/1&Form=FullRecordPage&doc=2/1>  (Guidi,
Luisa), Buti J
<http://apps.isiknowledge.com/WoS/CIW.cgi?SID=3C32OCP4@KPcf7gnOCk&Func=O
neClickSearch&field=AU&val=Buti+J&ut=000244978300011&auloc=4&fullauth=%2
0(Buti,%20Jacopo)&curr_doc=2/1&Form=FullRecordPage&doc=2/1>  (Buti,
Jacopo), Franceschi D
<http://apps.isiknowledge.com/WoS/CIW.cgi?SID=3C32OCP4@KPcf7gnOCk&Func=O
neClickSearch&field=AU&val=Franceschi+D&ut=000244978300011&auloc=5&fulla
uth=%20(Franceschi,%20Debora)&curr_doc=2/1&Form=FullRecordPage&doc=2/1>
(Franceschi, Debora), Mauro S
<http://apps.isiknowledge.com/WoS/CIW.cgi?SID=3C32OCP4@KPcf7gnOCk&Func=O
neClickSearch&field=AU&val=Mauro+S&ut=000244978300011&auloc=6&fullauth=%
20(Mauro,%20Saverio)&curr_doc=2/1&Form=FullRecordPage&doc=2/1>  (Mauro,
Saverio), Pini-Prato G
<http://apps.isiknowledge.com/WoS/CIW.cgi?SID=3C32OCP4@KPcf7gnOCk&Func=O
neClickSearch&field=AU&val=Pini-Prato+G&ut=000244978300011&auloc=7&fulla
uth=%20(Pini-Prato,%20GiovanPaolo)&curr_doc=2/1&Form=FullRecordPage&doc=
2/1>  (Pini-Prato, GiovanPaolo) 

Source: JOURNAL OF CLINICAL PERIODONTOLOGY 34 (4): 349-358 APR 2007 

Document Type: Review 

Language: English 

Cited References: 146
<http://apps.isiknowledge.com/WoS/CIW.cgi?SID=3C32OCP4@KPcf7gnOCk&Func=P
agedCitedRefList&UT=000244978300011&doc=2/1&rec_id=155048858>
Times Cited: 0       
<http://apps.isiknowledge.com/WoS/CIW.cgi?SID=3C32OCP4@KPcf7gnOCk&Func=E
asyRelated&UT=000244978300011&doc=2/1&rec_id=155048858>   
<javascript:void();>  

Abstract: Aim: The aims of this study were to identify the most cited
articles in Periodontology published from January 1990 to March 2005;
and to analyse the differences between citation Classics and less cited
articles. 

Material and Methods: The search was carried out in four international
periodontal journals: Journal of Periodontology, Journal of Clinical
Periodontology, International Journal of Periodontics and Restorative
Dentistry and Journal of Periodontal Research. The Classics, that are
articles cited at least 100 times, were identified using the Science
Citation Index database. From every issue of the journals that contained
a Classic, another article was randomly selected and used as a Control.

Results: Fifty-five Classics and 55 Controls were identified. Classic
articles were longer, used more images, had more authors, and contained
more self-references than Controls.

Moreover Classics had on the average a bigger sample size, often dealt
with etiopathogenesis and prognosis, but were rarely controlled or
randomized studies.

Conclusions: Classic articles play an instructive role, but are often
non-Controlled studies.

Author Keywords: citation Classics; controlled study; methodological
quality; number of authors; number of pages; periodontology; sample
size; Science Citation Index; self-references; St. Matthew's effect 

KeyWords Plus: GUIDED TISSUE REGENERATION; GINGIVAL CREVICULAR FLUID;
DEPENDENT DIABETES-MELLITUS; HUMAN INTRABONY DEFECTS; HUMAN INFRABONY
DEFECTS; FREEZE-DRIED BONE; ACTINOBACILLUS-ACTINOMYCETEMCOMITANS;
CIGARETTE-SMOKING; RISK INDICATORS; GROWTH-FACTORS 

Addresses: Pini-Prato G (reprint author), Viale Matteotti 11, I-50121
Florence, Italy
Univ Florence, Dept Periodontol, Florence, Italy

E-mail Addresses: gpinipr at tin.it <mailto:gpinipr at tin.it>  

Publisher: BLACKWELL PUBLISHING, 9600 GARSINGTON RD, OXFORD OX4 2DQ,
OXON, ENGLAND 

Subject Category: Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine 

IDS Number: 147BL 

Cited References: AH MKB, 1994, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V21, P91.
AKALIN FA, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P323.
AKSNES DW, 2003, RES EVALUAT, V12, P159.
AKSNES DW, 2003, SCIENTOMETRICS, V56, P235.
ALBERT DM, 1988, ARCH OPHTHALMOL-CHIC, V106, P465.
ALI RW, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P540.
ANDEREGG CR, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P264.
ARONSON JK, 2004, BRIT J CLIN PHARMACO, V58, S699.
AXELSSON P, 1991, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V18, P182.
BALTUSSEN A, 2004, ANESTH ANALG, V98, P443.
BALTUSSEN A, 2004, INTENS CARE MED, V30, P902.
BECK JD, 1990, J PERIODONTOL, V61, P521.
BECKER W, 1990, INT J PERIODONT REST, V10, P376.
BECKER W, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P929.
BERGAMASCHI O, 1993, INT J PERIODONT REST, V13, P85.
BERGSTROM J, 1994, J PERIODONTOL, V65, P545.
BIRKEDALHANSEN H, 1993, J PERIODONTAL RES 2, V28, P500.
BIRKEDALHANSEN H, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P474.
BOLTCHI FE, 2000, J PERIODONTOL, V71, P1641.
BOYNE PJ, 1997, INT J PERIODONT REST, V17, P11.
BROOKS TA, 1985, J AM SOC INFORM SCI, V36, P223.
BRUER JT, 1982, AM J PUBLIC HEALTH, V72, P1119.
BURRELL QL, 2003, J AM SOC INF SCI TEC, V54, P372.
BUSER D, 1993, INT J PERIODONT REST, V13, P29.
CAFFESSE RG, 1990, J PERIODONTOL, V61, P510.
CALLAHAM M, 2002, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V287, P2847.
CARNEVALE G, 1990, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V17, P313.
CHILDS WC, 1990, J PERIODONTAL RES, V25, P172.
COBB CM, 1990, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V17, P371.
CORTELLINI P, 1990, INT J PERIODONT REST, V10, P392.
CORTELLINI P, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P254.
CORTELLINI P, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P261.
CORTELLINI P, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P387.
CORTELLINI P, 1996, J PERIODONTOL, V67, P217.
DAWSON AG, 1989, TRENDS BIOCHEM SCI, V14, P326.
DMYTRYK JJ, 1990, J PERIODONTOL, V61, P491.
DODSON SA, 1996, J PERIODONTOL, V67, P184.
DONNER A, 1991, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V18, P755.
DUBIN D, 1993, ARCH DERMATOL, V129, P1121.
DUMONT JE, 1989, TRENDS BIOCHEM SCI, V14, P327.
EMRICH LJ, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P123.
FEDI PF, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P24.
FENTON JE, 2002, J LARYNGOL OTOL, V116, P494.
FINE DH, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P383.
FLEMMIG TF, 1998, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V25, P158.
GARFIELD E, 1955, SCIENCE, V122, P108.
GARFIELD E, 1987, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V257, P52.
GENCO RJ, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P338.
GILBERT GN, 1977, SOC STUD SCI, V7, P113.
GILLETT IR, 1990, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V17, P673.
GLANZEL W, 1992, RES EVALUAT, V2, P135.
GLANZEL W, 1997, SCIENTOMETRICS, V40, P481.
GOODSON JM, 1991, J PERIODONTAL RES, V26, P371.
GRBIC JT, 1995, J PERIODONTOL, V66, P55.
GROSSI SG, 1994, J PERIODONTOL, V65, P260.
GROSSI SG, 1995, J PERIODONTOL, V66, P23.
GUSTAFSSON A, 1995, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V22, P225.
HABER J, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P16.
HAFFAJEE AD, 1997, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V24, P324.
HALL GM, 1998, BRIT J ANAESTH, V80, P4.
HANES P, 1991, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V18, P567.
HARASZTHY VI, 2000, J PERIODONTOL, V71, P1554.
HART TC, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P169.
HART TC, 1994, J PERIODONTOL, V65, P521.
HOLT RD, 1995, J PERIODONTOL, V66, P97.
ISHIHARA Y, 1991, J PERIODONTAL RES, V26, P155.
JAFFIN RA, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P2.
JORKJEND L, 1990, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V17, P341.
KALDAHL WB, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P243.
KINGMAN A, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P477.
KLAUSEN B, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P59.
KORNMAN KS, 1997, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V24, P72.
LAMSTER IB, 1991, J PERIODONTAL RES, V26, P261.
LANG NP, 1990, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V17, P714.
LINDEN GJ, 1991, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V18, P177.
LISTGARTEN MA, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P332.
LIU MX, 1993, J DOC, V49, P370.
LYNCH SE, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P458.
MACFARLANE GD, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P908.
MACGREGOR IDM, 1997, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V24, P335.
MACHTEI EE, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P968.
MACROBERTS MH, 1996, SCIENTOMETRICS, V36, P435.
MANGAN DF, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P461.
MASADA MP, 1990, J PERIODONTAL RES, V25, P156.
MATSUDA N, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P515.
MCCULLOCH CAG, 1991, J PERIODONTAL RES, V26, P144.
MERTON RK, 1968, SCIENCE, V159, P56.
MEYLE J, 1993, J PERIODONTAL RES 2, V28, P491.
MIYASAKI KT, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P761.
MOMBELLI A, 1991, J PERIODONTAL RES, V26, P308.
MOORE WEC, 1991, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V18, P729.
MORROW DJ, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P63.
NAGY RJ, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P954.
NERY EB, 1990, J PERIODONTOL, V61, P166.
NIEMINEN A, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P297.
NIKOSKELAINEN J, 1990, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V17, P504.
NOVAES AB, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P116.
OFFENBACHER S, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P432.
OLLERTON JE, 2005, J TRAUMA, V58, P364.
OSBORN J, 1990, J PERIODONTOL, V61, P497.
PAGE RC, 1991, J PERIODONTAL RES, V26, P230.
PALADUGU R, 2002, WORLD J SURG, V26, P1099.
PERNEGER TV, 2004, BRIT MED J, V329, P546.
PETERS HPF, 1994, J AM SOC INFORM SCI, V45, P39.
PICHAPPAN P, 2002, SCIENTOMETRICS, V54, P285.
PINIPRATO GP, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P919.
PREBER H, 1990, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V17, P324.
QUIRYNEN M, 1995, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V22, P1.
RANGACHIARI PK, 1994, ADV PHYSIOL EDUC, V267, P120.
RENVERT S, 1990, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V17, P345.
RENVERT S, 1995, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V22, P63.
RODENBURG JP, 1990, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V17, P392.
ROSSMANN JA, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P902.
ROWLAND RW, 1993, J PERIODONTAL RES 2, V28, P514.
SALVI GE, 1997, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V24, P8.
SEGLEN PO, 1992, J AM SOC INFORM SCI, V43, P628.
SEGLEN PO, 1997, ALLERGY, V52, P1050.
SEIBERT J, 1990, J PERIODONTOL, V61, P157.
SELVIG KA, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P974.
SEYMOUR GJ, 1993, J PERIODONTAL RES 2, V28, P478.
SIGURDSSON TJ, 1995, J PERIODONTOL, V66, P131.
SLOTS J, 1990, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V17, P479.
SOCRANSKY SS, 1991, J PERIODONTAL RES, V26, P195.
SOCRANSKY SS, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P322.
SOCRANSKY SS, 1998, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V25, P134.
STABHOLZ A, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P429.
STASHENKO P, 1991, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V18, P548.
STASHENKO P, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P504.
SWIETER M, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P492.
TAGLIACOZZO R, 1977, J DOC, V33, P251.
TAICHMAN NS, 1991, J PERIODONTAL RES, V26, P258.
TERAJIMA K, 2003, ACTA ANAESTH SCAND, V47, P655.
TINTI C, 1997, INT J PERIODONT REST, V17, P53.
TONETTI MS, 1993, J PERIODONTOL, V64, P934.
TONETTI MS, 1995, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V22, P229.
TURESKY S, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P871.
VANDERWEIJDEN GA, 1994, J CLIN PERIODONTOL, V21, P139.
VANWINKELHOFF AJ, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P52.
VOGEL RI, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P914.
VOOS H, 1976, J ACAD LIBR, V1, P19.
WHITE JM, 1994, J PERIODONTOL, V65, P255.
WHITE MD, 1997, LIBR QUART, V67, P122.
WIKESJO UME, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P258.
WIKESJO UME, 1992, J PERIODONTOL, V63, P158.
YAMALIK N, 1991, J PERIODONTOL, V62, P737.
YITZHAKI M, 2002, SCIENTOMETRICS, V54, P435.

Cited Reference Count: 146

Times Cited: 0

Publisher: BLACKWELL PUBLISHING; 9600 GARSINGTON RD, OXFORD OX4 2DQ,
OXON, ENGLAND

Subject Category: Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine

ISSN: 0303-6979

When responding, please attach my original message
__________________________________________________
Eugene Garfield, PhD. email:  garfield at codex.cis.upenn.edu 
home page: www.eugenegarfield.org <http://www.eugenegarfield.org/> 
Tel: 215-243-2205 Fax 215-387-1266

Chairman Emeritus, ISI www.isinet.com <http://www.isinet.com/>  
3501 Market Street, Philadelphia, PA 19104-3302
President, The Scientist LLC. www.the-scientist.com
<http://www.the-scientist.com/>    
400 Market Street, Suite 1250, Philadelphia, PA 19106-2501
Past President, American Society for Information Science and Technology
(ASIS&T) www.asist.org  

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mail.asis.org/pipermail/sigmetrics/attachments/20070406/6f37dc92/attachment.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: image001.gif
Type: image/gif
Size: 931 bytes
Desc: image001.gif
URL: <http://mail.asis.org/pipermail/sigmetrics/attachments/20070406/6f37dc92/attachment.gif>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: image002.gif
Type: image/gif
Size: 345 bytes
Desc: image002.gif
URL: <http://mail.asis.org/pipermail/sigmetrics/attachments/20070406/6f37dc92/attachment-0001.gif>