Lowe A, Locke J. " Perceptions of journal quality and research paradigm: results of a web-based survey of British accounting academics" ACCOUNTING ORGANIZATIONS AND SOCIETY 30 (1): 81-98 JAN 2005

[Eugene Garfield]

E-mail Addresses:
A. Lowe :  alowe1 at waikato.ac.nz
J. Locke:  jlocke at waikato.ac.nz

Title    : Perceptions  of journal quality and research paradigm: results of
           a web-based survey of British accounting academics

Author(s): Lowe A, Locke J

Source    : ACCOUNTING ORGANIZATIONS AND SOCIETY 30 (1): 81-98 JAN 2005

Document Type: Article
Language: English
Cited References: 55      Times Cited: 0

Abstract: This paper reports the results of a web-based perception study of
the ranking of peer reviewed accounting journals by UK academics. The design
of the survey instrument allows an interactive selection of journals to be
scored. The web-based format is unique in that it also includes a step in
which respondents classify the journals according to methodological
perspective (paradigm). This is depicted graphically in the paper in a
bubble diagram that shows the "positioning" of journals according to
perceptions of both paradigm and quality. (C) 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights
reserved.

Addresses: Lowe A (reprint author), Univ Waikato, Sch Management, Dept
Accounting, Private Bag 3105, Hamilton, New Zealand
Univ Waikato, Sch Management, Dept Accounting, Hamilton, New Zealand

Publisher: PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD, THE BOULEVARD, LANGFORD LANE,
KIDLINGTON, OXFORD OX5 1GB, ENGLAND
Subject Category: BUSINESS, FINANCE
IDS Number: 863WF
ISSN: 0361-3682

CITED REFERENCES:

  *AM ACC ASS, 1977, ACCOUNTING REV S, V52, P65
   ALVESSON M, 2000, DOING CRITICAL MANAG
   BAKER CR, 1997, CRIT PERSPECT, V8, P293
   BALLAS A, 2002, FACULTY PERCEPTIONS
   BALLAS A, 2003, CONTEMP ACCOUNT RES, V20, P619
   BEATLEY T, 2001, ALTERN J, V27, P32
   BEATTIE VA, 1989, BR ACCOUNT REV, V21, P267
   BELKAOUI A, 1991, COMING CRISIS
   BENJAMIN JJ, 1974, ACCOUNT REV, V49, P360
   BHIMANI A, 2002, EUROPEAN ACCOUTING R, V11, P99
   BOYER KK, 2001, DECISION LINE, V32, P4
   BRICKER R, 1989, J ACCOUNTING RES, V27, P246
   BRINN T, 1996, ACCOUNT BUSINESS RES, V26, P265
   BRINN T, 1998, BRIT ACCOUNTING REV, V30, P313
   BRINN T, 2001, BRIT ACCOUNTING REV, V33, P223
   BROWN LD, 1985, J ACCOUNTING RES, V23, P84
   BROWN LD, 1987, ACCOUNT ORG SOC, V12, P193
   BROWN LD, 1994, CONTEMP ACCOUNT RES, V11, P223
   CARTA JJ, 1995, FOCUS EXCEPT CHILD, V27, P1
   CASSAR G, 1999, ACCOUNTING ACCOUNTAB, V5, P1
   CHRISTENSON C, 1983, ACCOUNT REV, V58, P1
   CHUA WF, 1986, ACCOUNT REV, V61, P601
   CHUA WF, 1988, ACCOUNTING AUDITING, V1, P59
   CLARKE FJ, 1999, CRIT PERSPECT, V10, P65
   CROOM DL, 1970, DANGERS USE CITATION, P1173
   EVERETT JE, 1991, OCCASIONAL PAPER SER, V91
   GAFFIKIN MJR, 1988, ABACUS, V24, P16
   GARFIELD E, 1975, CURR CONTENTS, P5
   GRAY R, 2002, ACCOUNTING FORUM, V26, P1
   HASSELBACK JR, 1995, ISSUES ACCOUNTING ED, V10, P269
   HASSELBACK JR, 2000, J ACCOUNTING ED, V18, P79
   HELLIAR C, 2002, BRIT ACCOUNTING REV
   HOUGHTON KA, 1984, INT J ACCOUNTING ED, V20, P179
   HOWARD TP, 1983, ACCOUNT REV, V58, P765
   HULL RP, 1990, ACCOUNTING HORIZONS, V4, P77
   LEE TA, 1999, CRIT PERSPECT, V10, P867
   LIU SX, 1993, ACTA CRYSTALLOGR C, V49, P4
   LOCKE J, 2002, ACCOUNTING FORUM, V26, P45
   LOWE A, 2002, WORKING PAPER SERIES, V75
   MACROBERTS MH, 1989, J AM SOC INFORM SCI, V40, P342
   MCNULTY JE, 1999, J EC FINANCE, V23, P30
   MILNE MJ, 1999, ACCOUNTING ACCOUNTAB, V6, P99
   MORGAN SL, 1993, ARTHRIT CARE RES, V6, P4
   MORRIS JL, 1990, ACCOUNTING ED J, V3, P46
   NOBES CW, 1985, ACCOUNT REV, V60, P702
   OTLEY DT, 2002, BRIT ACCOUNTING REV, V34, P387
   PARKER L, 1998, ACCOUNTING AUDITING, V11, P371
   REINSTEIN A, 1997, J ACCOUNTING ED, V15, P425
   REITER SA, 2002, ACCOUNT ORG SOC, V27, P575
   RIAHIBELKAOUI A, 1996, ACCOUNTING MULTIPARA
   TAHAI A, 1998, INFORM PROCESS MANAG, V34, P341
   TINKER T, 1995, POLICING ACCOUNTING
   VEHOVAR V, 2000, 13 INT BLED EL COMM
   WILLIAMS PF, 1995, CRIT PERSPECT, V6, P263
   ZEFF SA, 1996, ACCOUNTING HORIZONS, V10, P158