Bensman SJ " Urquhart and probability: The transition from librarianship to library and information science" JASIST 56 (2). JAN 15 2005. p.189-214

[Stephen J Bensman]

Gee, thanks, Gene, for noticing my article, although it is hard to miss due
to its size.  For those of you interested, Julie Hurd is publishing in her
journal Science and Technical Libraries a three-part article, in which I
explain with simple math and graphic techniques the probability
distributions underlying library use.  I have designed it, so that
practitioner librarians and library school students can learn to utlize
probability distributions to manage sci/tech journal collections and
databases, using Urquhart's ideas as a starting model.  Like this article,
Maurice B. Line has vetted it.  Those of you interested can contact me for
prepubs of this article--Julie permitting.  A number library school
professors said such an article was needed.  I must warn you, though--it
ain't the high-falutin', rootin'-tootin', $25 math most of you people are
interested in.

Steve B.






Eugene Garfield <garfield at CODEX.CIS.UPENN.EDU>@LISTSERV.UTK.EDU> on
02/21/2005 01:15:48 PM

Please respond to ASIS&T Special Interest Group on Metrics
       <SIGMETRICS at LISTSERV.UTK.EDU>

Sent by:    ASIS&T Special Interest Group on Metrics
       <SIGMETRICS at LISTSERV.UTK.EDU>


To:    SIGMETRICS at LISTSERV.UTK.EDU
cc:     (bcc: Stephen J Bensman/notsjb/LSU)

Subject:    [SIGMETRICS] Bensman SJ " Urquhart and probability: The
       transition from librarianship to library and information science"
       JASIST 56 (2). JAN 15 2005. p.189-214

E-mail Addresses: notsjb at lsu.edu

TITLE:          Urquhart and probability: The transition from
                librarianship to library and information science (Article,
English)
AUTHOR:         Bensman, SJ
SOURCE:         JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR INFORMATION SCIENCE
                AND TECHNOLOGY 56 (2). JAN 15 2005. p.189-214 JOHN WILEY
                & SONS INC, HOBOKEN

ABSTRACT:       In this article, I analyze the role of Donald J. Urquhart
in the creation of modern library and information science. Urquhart was one
of the chief architects of information science in Britain and founder of
the
National Lending Library for Science and Technology (NLL), which evolved
into the present-day British Library Document Supply Centre (BLDSC). In
particular, I focus on the part played by Urquhart in the development of
that branch of information science termed bibliometrics, the application of
mathematical and statistical techniques to information phenomena, pursuing
both historical and practical aims. The article is intended not only to
trace the history of the probability distributions applicable to library
use
and other facets of human knowledge but also to demonstrate how these
distributions can be used in the evaluation and management of scientific
journal collections. For these purposes, the paper is divided into three
parts of equal importance. The first part is statistical and establishes
the
theoretical framework, within which Urquhart's work is considered. It
traces
the historical development of the applicable probability distributions,
discussing their origins on the European continent and how Continental
principles became incorporated in the biometric statistics that arose in
Britain as a result of the Darwinian revolution. This part analyzes the
binomial and Poisson processes, laying out the reasons why the Poisson
process is more suitable for modeling information phenomena. In doing so,
it
describes key distributions arising from these processes as well as the
various tests for these distributions, citing the literature that shows how
to conduct these tests. Throughout the discussion, the relationship of
these
distributions to library use and the laws of information science is-
emphasized. The second part of the article analyzes the pioneering role of
Urquhart as a conduit for the entry of these probability distributions into
librarianship, converting it into library and information science.
He was the first librarian to apply probability to library use, utilizing
it
not only to establish and manage the scientific journal collections of the
NLL but also to evolve his Law of Supralibrary Use. Urquhart's work is
portrayed within the context of a general trend to adopt probabilistic
methods for analytical purposes, and a major premise of this article is
that
his law and the probabilistic breakthrough, on which it was based, were
most
likely in Britain. which was one of the few countries not only to develop
but also maintain the necessary scientific preconditions. The third-and
concluding section-discusses how Urquhart's Law forces a probabilistic
reconceptualization of the functioning of the scientific journal system as
well as the law's practical implications for journal sales, collection
evaluation and management, resource sharing, and the transition from the
paper to the electronic format.

AUTHOR ADDRESS: SJ Bensman, Louisiana State Univ, LSU Lib, Baton Rouge, LA
                70803 USA
Louisiana State Univ, LSU Lib, Baton Rouge, LA 70803 USA

Publisher: JOHN WILEY & SONS INC, 111 RIVER ST, HOBOKEN, NJ 07030 USA
Subject Category: COMPUTER SCIENCE, INFORMATION SYSTEMS; INFORMATION
SCIENCE
& LIBRARY SCIENCE

IDS Number: 890JU
ISSN: 1532-2882

Cited References:
1907, BIOMETRIKA, V5, P351
   1919, BIOMETRIKA, V12, P211
   *BRIT LIBR DOC SUP, 1996, COMP SUT ACC J SUBSC
   BENSMAN SJ, 1998, LIBR RESOUR TECH SER, V42, P147
   BENSMAN SJ, 2001, ASSESSMENT AGGREGATO
   BENSMAN SJ, 2001, IFLA J, V27, P238
   BENSMAN SJ, 2001, J AM SOC INF SCI TEC, V52, P714
   BOWER CA, 1976, BLL REV, V4, P31
   BUNN RM, 1957, ASLIB P, V9, P280
   BUNN RM, 1958, ASLIB P, V10, P251
   BUNN RM, 1962, J DOC, V18, P20
   CAMIC C, 1994, AM SOCIOL REV, V59, P773
   CATTELL JM, 1906, SCIENCE, V24, P658
   CATTELL JM, 1910, SCIENCE, V32, P633
   CATTELL JM, 1910, SCIENCE, V32, P672
   CLARKE A, 1981, INTERLENDING REV, V9, P111
   COCHRAN WG, 1954, BIOMETRICS, V10, P417
   COELMAN JS, 1964, INTRO MATH SOCIOLOGY
   DESOLLA PDJ, 1963, LITTLE SCI BIG SCI
   EGGEBERGER F, 1923, COLLECTED PAPERS G P, V4, P94
   EHRENBERG ASC, 1959, APPLIED STATISTICS, V8, P26
   ELLIOTT JM, 1977, FRESHWATER BIOL ASS, V25
   EVANS GE, 2000, LIBR INORMATIN SCI T
   FELLER W, 1943, ANN MATH STAT, V14, P389
   FISHER A, 1922, MATH THEORY PROBABIL, V1
   FISHER RA, 1925, STAT METHODS RES WOR, V5
   FUSSLER HH, 1969, PATTERNS USE BOOKS L
   GALTON F, 1874, ENGLISH SCI NATURE N
   GALTON F, 1892, HEREDITARY GENIUS IN
   GREENWOOD M, 1920, J ROY STATIST SOC  A, V83, P255
   GRIFFITHS DA, 1973, BIOMETRICS, V29, P637
   HAIGHT FA, 1967, PULBICATIONS OPERATI
   HAIGHT FA, 1978, INT ENCY STAT, V1, P155
   HOUGHTON B, 1972, DINOSAURS EVOLUTION
   JOHNSON NL, 1969, DISCRETE DISTRIBUTIO
   KATZ B, 2000, MAGAZINE LIBR
   KEYNES JM, 1921, TREATISE PROBABILITY
   KOSKO B, 1993, FUZZ THINKING NEW SC
   KURTH WH, 1962, SURVEY INTERLIBRARY
   LINE MB, 1974, J DOC, V30, P283
   LINE MB, 1975, J DOC, V31, P234
   LINE MB, 1976, J DOC, V32, P322
   LINE MB, 1977, J DOC, V33, P151
   MERRY K, 1984, INTERLENDING DOCUMEN, V12, P56
   MORAN PAP, 1968, INTRO PROBABILITY TH
   MORONEY MJ, 1956, FACTS FIGURES
   NEWBOLD EM, 1927, J R STAT SOC 3, V90, P487
   PATIL GP, 1968, DICT BIBLIOGRAPHY DI
   PEARSON ES, 1966, BIOMETRIKA TABLES ST, V1
   PEARSON K, 1894, PHILOS T ROY SOC A, V185, P71
   PEARSON K, 1895, PHILOS T ROY SOC A, V186, P343
   PEARSON K, 1900, PHILOSOPHICAL MAGA 5, V50, P157
   PEARSON K, 1901, PHILOS T ROY SOC A, P443
   PEARSON K, 1916, PHIL T A, V216, P429
   PRICE AL, 1993, SERIALS REV, V19, P79
   PRICE DJD, 1976, J AM SOC INFORM SCI, V27, P292
   PRITCHARD A, 1969, J DOC, V25, P348
   RIETZ HL, 1924, HDB MATH STAT, P82
   RIETZ HL, 1927, CARUS MATH MONOGRAPH, V3
   SCALES PA, 1976, J DOC, V32, P17
   SNEDECOR GW, 1989, STAT METHODS
   STEWART B, 1976, FAREWELL ALEXANDIRA, P105
   URQUHART DJ, 1957, J DOC, V13, P13
   URQUHART DJ, 1959, J DOC, V15, P21
   URQUHART DJ, 1959, P INT C SCI INF WASH, V1, P287
   URQUHART DJ, 1959, UNESCO B LIBR, V13, P173
   URQUHART DJ, 1960, P PAP DISC SCARB C L, P51
   URQUHART DJ, 1962, LIBRARY ASS RECORD, V64, P319
   URQUHART DJ, 1963, J DOC, V19, P86
   URQUHART DJ, 1977, J DOC, V33, P149
   URQUHART DJ, 1981, PRINCIPLES LIBR
   URQUHART DJ, 1986, RES PRACT LIBR INT S, P21
   URQUHART DJ, 1990, BOSTON SPA
   URQUHART JA, 1976, RELEGATION STOCK CON
   URQUHART JA, 1977, ASLIB P, V29, P32
   URQUHART JA, 1978, PERIODICALS ADM LIBR, P116
   URQUHART JA, 1982, INTERLENDING REV, V10, P97
   WELDON WFR, 1890, P ROYAL SOC, V47, P445
   WELDON WFR, 1893, P ROYAL SOC, V54, P318
   WINSOR CP, 1947, HUM BIOL, V19, P154
   WOOD JL, 1969, REV AVAILABILITY PRI, V1