McElhinny B, Hols M, Holtzkener J, Unger S, Hicks C. "Gender, publication and citation in sociolinguistics and linguistic anthropology: The construction of a scholarly canon" LANGUAGE IN SOCIETY 32 (3): 299-328 JUN 2003
Eugene Garfield
garfield at CODEX.CIS.UPENN.EDU
Mon Sep 29 15:11:48 EDT 2003
Bonnie McElhinny : bonnie.mcelhinny at utoronto.ca
TITLE : Gender, publication and citation in sociolinguistics and
linguistic anthropology: The construction of a scholarly canon
AUTHOR : McElhinny B, Hols M, Holtzkener J, Unger S, Hicks C
jOURNAL : LANGUAGE IN SOCIETY 32 (3): 299-328 JUN 2003
Document type: Article Language: English
Cited References: 99 Times Cited: 0
Abstract:
Feminist scholars have begun to ask how existing conceptual schemes and
organizational structures in academic disciplines have excluded women and
feminist ideas,and to provide suggestions for transformation. One strand of
this work has been the exploration of how canons of thought are constructed
in such fields as economics, sociology, and sociocultural anthropology. This
article begins such an investigation for sociolinguistics and linguistic
anthropology by reviewing how gender correlates with publication and
citation over a 35-year period (1965-2000) in five key journals, and in 16
textbooks published in the 1990s. It describes some marked differences in
the publication of works by women and on gender in the five journals, as
well as some significant differences in the degree to which men
and women cite the work of women. It also considers how the rate of
publication of articles on sex, gender, and women is correlated with
publication of female authors. It concludes with a discussion of the
implications of this study for changing institutional practices in our
field.
Author Keywords:
gender, publication, citation, academic discourse, feminist theory, canons
KeyWords Plus:
CONVERSATION ANALYSIS, INTERPRETATIVE REPERTOIRES, LANGUAGE,
POSTSTRUCTURALISM, COMMUNITY, FEMINISM,
JOURNALS, DIALOGUE, CONTEXT
Addresses:
McElhinny B, Univ Toronto, Dept Anthropol, 100 St George St,Room 1052,
Toronto, ON M5S 3G3, Canada
Univ Toronto, Dept Anthropol, Toronto, ON M5S 3G3, Canada
Publisher:
CAMBRIDGE UNIV PRESS, 40 WEST 20TH ST, NEW YORK, NY 10011-4221 USA
IDS Number:
682VM
ISSN:
0047-4045
Cited Author Cited Work Volume Page Year
ID
AGAR M LANGUAGE SHOCK UNDER 1994
ALCOFF L SIGNS 13 405 1988
AMORY D ANTHR LOCATIONS BOUN 102 1997
BAKANIC V AM SOCIOL REV 52 631 1987
BEHAR R WOMEN WRITING CULTUR 1995
BENOR S GENDERED PRACTICES L 2002
BILLIG M DISCOURSE SOC 10 543 1999
BING J LANGUAGE GENDER RES 1996
BONVILLAIN N LANGUAGE CULTURE COM 2000
BUTLER J GENDER TROUBLE FEMIN 1990
CAMERON D FEMINISM LINGUISTIC 1992
CAMERON D IDEOLOGIES LANGUAGE 79 1990
CAMERON D WOMEN THEIR SPEECH C 13 1988
CHAMBERS JK SOCIOLINGUISTIC THEO 1995
CHRISTIAN B CULTURAL CRITIQUE 6 51 1987
CLIFFORD J WRITING CULTURE POET 1986
COLLINS PH BLACK FEMINIST THOUG 1990
COZZENS SE SCIENTOMETRICS 15 437 1989
DERRIDA J DERRIDA READER 80 1991
DERRIDA J LTD INC 1988
DUNN C ANTHR NEWS 40 64 1999
DURANTI A GRAMMAR POLITICS LIN 1994
DURANTI A LINGUISTIC ANTHR 1997
ECKERT P ANNU REV ANTHROPOL 21 461 1992
ECKERT P LANGUAGE VARIATION C 1 245 1989
ECKERT P LINGUISTIC VARIATION 2000
EICHLER M DOUBLE STANDARD FEMI 1980
FASOLD R INTRO SOCIOLINGUISTI 2 1990
FASOLD R INTRO SOCIOLINGUISTI 1 1984
FERBER MA SIGNS 11 381 1986
FIGUEROA E SOCIOLINGUISTIC META 1994
FOLEY W ANTHR LINGUISTICS IN 1997
FREEDMAN D STATISTICS 1991
FRIEND P BRIT J SOC CLIN PSYC 18 77 1979
GAL S GENDER CROSSROADS KN 175 1991
GARFIELD E CURR ANTHROPOL 25 514 1984
GILBERT GN SOC STUD SCI 7 113 1977
GOODWIN MH HE SAID SHE SAID TAL 1990
GUILLORY J CULTURAL CAPITAL PRO 1993
GUPTA A ANTHR LOCATIONS BOUN 1 1997
HALL K GENDER ARTICULATED 1995
HAMERMESH DS SO EC J 49 472 1982
HANKS W LANGUAGE COMMUNICATI 1996
HARDING S FEMINIST EPISTEMOLOG 49 1993
HARDING S SCI QUESTION FEMINIS 1986
HARDING S WHOSE SCI WHOSE KNOW 1991
HARRISON FV ANNU REV ANTHROPOL 24 47 1995
HARTSTOCK N DISCOVERING REALITY 1983
HERZFELD M ANTHR THEORETICAL PR 2001
HOLMES J INTRO SOCIOLINGUISTI 1992
HOLMES J LANGUAGE SOC 28 1992
HUDSON RA SOCIOLINGUISTICS 1996
HYDE JS FEMINIST RES METHODS 207 1990
HYMES D FDN SOCIOLINGUISTICS 1974
JAGGAR A FEMINIST POLITICS HU 1983
KINGSBURY H MUSIC TALENT PERFORM 1988
KITZINGER C FEM PSYCHOL 10 163 2000
KUHN T STRUCTURE SCI REVOLU 1970
KULICK D ANNU REV ANTHROPOL 29 243 2000
LAKOFF R LANGUAGE WOMANS PLAC 1975
LUTZ C AM ETHNOL 17 611 1990
MACAULAY R SOCIAL ART LANGUAGE 1994
MCCONNELLGINET S WOMEN LANGUAGE LIT S 1980
MCELHINNY B GENDER BELIEF SYSTEM 469 1996
MCELHINNY B GENDER DISCOURSE 106 1997
MCELHINNY B LANGUAGE GENDER HDB 21 2003
MILROY L LANGUAGE SOCIAL NETW 1980
MORAVCSIK MJ SOC STUD SCI 18 515 1988
MORGAN M LANGUAGE DISCOURSE P 2002
MORGAN M REINVENTING IDENTITI 7 1999
MURRAY S AM SOCIOLINGUISTICS 1998
MURRAY S GROUP FORMATION SOCI 1983
OCHS E RETHINKING CONTEXT L 335 1992
OCHS E RETHINKING LINGUISTI 407 1996
ORAND A WOMEN NEW ACAD GENDE 103 1989
PALMER G THEORY CULTURAL LING 1996
QUEEN R LANGUAGE SEXUALITY C 69 2002
RICKFORD JR LANG SOC 26 161 1997
ROMAINE S LANGUAGE SOC INTRO S 1994
ROSALDO M WOMAN CULTURE SOC 1974
ROSALDO MZ SIGNS 5 389 1980
ROSALDO R CULTURE TRUTH REMARK 1993
SALZMANN Z LANGUAGE CULTURE SOC 1993
SCHEGLOFF EA DISCOURSE SOC 10 558 1999
SCHEGLOFF EA DISCOURSE SOC 9 413 1998
SCHEGLOFF EA DISCOURSE SOC 8 165 1997
SCHIEFFELIN BB ANNU REV ANTHROPOL 15 163 1986
SCOTT J AM HIST REV 91 1055 1986
SCOTT JW CONFLICTS FEMINISM 134 1990
SCOTT JW GENDER POLITICS HIST 178 1988
SMALL HG SOC STUD SCI 8 327 1978
SPENDER D DOING FEMINIST RES 186 1981
SPOLSKY B SOCIOLINGUISTICS 1998
STACEY J AM FEMINIST THOUGHT 167 1993
TANNEN D YOU JUST DONT UNDERS 1990
WARD KB SOCIOL QUART 26 139 1985
WARDHAUGH R INTRO SOCIOLINGUISTI 1992
WETHERELL M DISCOURSE SOC 9 387 1998
WOOLARD KA AM ETHNOL 12 738 1985
_______________________________________________________________________
Eugene Garfield, PhD. email: garfield at codex.cis.upenn.edu
home page: www.eugenegarfield.org
Tel: 215-243-2205 Fax 215-387-1266
President, The Scientist LLC. www.the-scientist.com
Chairman Emeritus, ISI www.isinet.com
Past President, American Society for Information Science and Technology
(ASIS&T) www.asis.org
_______________________________________________________________________
More information about the SIGMETRICS
mailing list