Keylock CJ, "Mark Melton's geomorphology and geography's quantitative revolution" Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 28(2):142-157, 2003
Eugene Garfield
garfield at CODEX.CIS.UPENN.EDU
Mon Aug 4 16:26:10 EDT 2003
Christopher J. Keylock : c.keylock at geog.leeds.ac.uk
Full Text Available at :
http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/links/doi/10.1111/1475-5661.00084/abs/
This paper contains some interesting citation analyses as reflected in
captions for Tables 1 and 2 and figures 1, 2, and 3. Also note "Sociologies
of Scientific Publication" on page 143 of this paper.
TITLE : Mark Melton's geomorphology and geography's
quantitative revolution
AUTHOR : Keylock CJ
JOURNAL: TRANSACTIONS OF THE INSTITUTE OF BRITISH GEOGRAPHERS
28 (2): 142-157 2003
Document type: Review Language: English
Cited References: 126 Times Cited: 0
Abstract:
Mark Melton published some important papers in the late 1950s that have had
a significant influence upon the subsequent development of geomorphology.
Two of these papers were published in the same journal in the same year, and
have a similar number of total citations, and these are compared in this
study. Although both papers present novel empirical findings and discuss
innovative conceptual frameworks, the extent and manner to which they have
been used within geography and geology differs quite markedly. This reveals
marked differences in the conceptual frameworks and research priorities of
the two groups of scientists, which may help explain why geomorphology has
proceeded differently on the two sides of the Atlantic since the
quantitative revolution.
Author Keywords:
quantitative revolution, geomorphology, history of ideas, methodology,
systems analysis, thermodynamics
KeyWords Plus:
NATURAL CHANNEL NETWORKS, FRACTAL RIVER NETWORKS, DRAINAGE SYSTEMS,
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSTRAINTS,
GEOLOGICAL-SOCIETY, AMERICA-BULLETIN, EVOLUTION, MODEL, SPACE, TIME
Addresses:
Keylock CJ, Univ Leeds, Sch Geog, Woodhouse Lane, Leeds LS2 9JT, W
Yorkshire, England
Univ Leeds, Sch Geog, Leeds LS2 9JT, W Yorkshire, England
Publisher:
INST BRITISH GEOGRAPHERS, LONDON
IDS Number:
695VT
ISSN:
0020-2754
Cited Author Cited Work Volume Page Year
ABRAHAMS AD GEOLOGICAL SOC AM B 84 353 1973
ABRAHAMS AD GEOLOGICAL SOC AM B 83 1523 1972
BAKER VR AM J SCI 278 97 1978
BANAVAR JR J STAT PHYS 104 1 2001
BARNES TJ ENVIRON PLANN A 34 487 2002
BARNES TJ ENVIRON PLANN A 30 203 1998
BARNES TJ ENVIRON PLANN D 19 409 2001
BARNES TJ LOGICS DISLOCATION 1996
BECKINSALE RP PROCESS FORM GEOMORP 3 1997
BERRY BJL ANN ASSOC AM GEOGR 48 83 1958
BUNGE W FIELD NOTES 1 1 1969
BUNGE W THEORETICAL GEOGRAPH 1962
CALDARELLI G PHYS REV E 1 63 2001
CHORLEY RJ ESSAYS GEOMORPHOLOGY 1966
CHORLEY RJ FRONTIERS GEOGRAPHIC 1965
CHORLEY RJ FRONTIERS GEOGRAPHIC 21 1965
CHORLEY RJ GEOMORPHOLOGY PRESEN 1 1978
CHORLEY RJ J GEOL 65 628 1957
CHORLEY RJ PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY 1971
CHORLEY RJ PROG PHYS GEOG 24 563 2000
CHORLEY RJ US GEOLOGICAL SURV B 500 1962
CHURCH M EARTH SURF PROCESSES 6 199 1981
CHURCH M PROGR PHYSICAL GEOGR 4 342 1980
COLLINS HM SOC STUD SCI 29 163 1999
CRONIN B SCIENTOMETRICS 54 31 2002
CULLING WEH J GEOL 73 230 1965
DAVID PA CREATION TRANSFER KN 1998
EMBLETON C GEOMORPHOLOGY PRESEN 1978
FIORENTINO M WATER RESOUR RES 29 1215* 1993
GARDINER V PROGR PHYSICAL GEOGR 2 1 1978
GREGORY KJ GEOMORPHOLOGY PRESEN 1978
HACK JT AM J SCI A 258 80 1960
HACK JT US GEOLOGICAL SURV B 294 1957
HAGGETT P GEOGR J 127 60 1961
HAGGETT P LOCATIONAL ANAL HUMA 1965
HAGGETT P PROGR HUMAN GEOGRAPH 15 302 1991
HARRISON W 7 US ARM COAST ENG R 1964
HARVEY D SOCIAL JUSTICE CITY 1973
HEPPLE LW ENVIRON PLANN D 19 385 2001
HORTON RE GEOL SOC AM BULL 56 275 1945
HOWARD AD WATER RESOUR RES 30 2261* 1994
IIJASZVASQUEZ EJ GEOMORPHOLOGY 5 297 1992
IJJASZVASQUEZ EJ GEOPHYS RES LETT 20 1583* 1993
JOHNSTON RJ AUSTR GEOGRAPHICAL S 38 125 2000
JOHNSTON RJ GEOGRAPHY GEOGRAPHER 1979
KENNEDY BA EARTH SURF PROCESSES 3 328 1978
KENNEDY BA GEOMORPHOLOGY 5 231 1992
KENNEDY BA THESIS U CAMBRIDGE 1965
KHINCHIN AI MATH FDN STAT MECH 1949
KIRKBY MJ Z GEOMORPHOLOGIE S 79 63 1990
KOONS D AM J SCI 253 53 1955
KRUMBEIN WC J SEDIMENT PETROL 29 575 1959
KUHN TS STRUCTURE SCI REVOLU 1962
LABARBERA P WATER RESOUR RES 25 735* 1989
LATOUR B SCI ACTION 1987
LAU SSS PROG PHYS GEOG 25 178 2001
LEOPOLD LB FLUVIAL PROCESSES GE 1964
LEOPOLD LB US GEOLOGICAL SURVEY 252 1953
LEY D ASS AM GEOGRAPHERS M 7 1974
LIVINGSTONE DN DISSEMINATING DARWIN 7 1999
MACKIN JH FABRIC GEOLOGY 1963
MACKIN JH GEOL SOC AM BULL 59 463 1948
MANDELBROT BB FRACTAL GEOMETRY NAT 1983
MARK DM MATH GEOL 9 63 1977
MCCARTY HH ANN ASSOC AM GEOGR 46 263 1956
MCCARTY HH ECON GEOGR 30 95 1954
MCCARTY HH MCCARTY MCCARTHY SPA 1954
MELTON MA 11 COL U DEP GEOL OF 1957
MELTON MA 16 COL U DEP GEOL OF 1958
MELTON MA GEOL SOC AM BULL 71 133 1960
MELTON MA GEOLOGICAL SOC AM B 69 355 1958
MELTON MA J GEOL 73 1 1965
MELTON MA J GEOL 73 715 1965
MELTON MA J GEOL 67 345 1959
MELTON MA J GEOL 66 35 1958
MELTON MA J GEOL 66 442 1958
MONTGOMERY K CAN GEOGR 35 345 1991
MORISAWA M GEOLOGICAL SOC AM B 100 1016 1988
MORISAWA ME J GEOL 66 587 1958
MORISAWA ME T AM GEOPHYSICAL UNI 38 86 1957
MURRAY AB WATER RESOUR RES 32 2579* 1996
ORME AR GEOMORPHOLOGY 47 325 2002
PEEL RF ADV SCI 24 205 1967
PHILLIPS JD J GEOL 100 365 1992
RHOADS BL SCI NATURE GEOMORPHO 21 1996
RICHARDS K EARTH SURF PROCESSES 15 195 1990
RICHARDS K SCI NATURE GEOMORPHO 171 1996
RICHARDS KS RIVERS FORM PROCESS 1982
RINALDO A PHYS REV LETT 70 822* 1993
ROBINSON AH ANN ASSOC AM GEOGR 46 233 1956
RODRIGUEZITURBE I FRACTAL RIVER BASINS 1997
SACK D GEOMORPHOLOGY 5 251 1992
SCHAEFER FK ANN ASSOC AM GEOGR 43 226 1953
SCHEIDEGGER AE WATER RESOUR RES 3 1041* 1967
SCHUMM SA AM J SCI 254 693 1956
SCHUMM SA DRAINAGE BASIN MORPH 1977
SCHUMM SA GEOL SOC AM BULL 67 597 1956
SCOTT AJ OXFORD HDB EC GEOGRA 2000
SHERMAN DJ SCI NATURE GEOMORPHO 87 1996
SHREVE RL J GEOL 75 178 1967
SHREVE RL J GEOL 74 17 1966
SMART JS GEOL SOC AM BULL 80 1757 1969
SMART JS GEOLOGICAL SOC AM B 84 351 1973
STARK CP AM J SCI 301 486 2001
STARK CP NATURE 352 423 1991
STODDART DR PROCESS FORM GEOMORP 383 1997
STRAHLER AN AM J SCI 248 673 1950
STRAHLER AN GEOL SOC AM BULL 69 27 1958
STRAHLER AN GEOL SOC AM BULL 63 1117 1952
STRAHLER AN J GEOL 62 1 1954
STRAHLER AN PROG PHYS GEOG 16 65 1992
STRAHLER AN T AM GEOPHYSICAL UNI 38 913 1957
TARBOTON DG J HYDROL 187 105 1996
THORNES JB GEOGRAPHY 70 222 1985
THORNES JB GEOMORPHOLOGY TIME 1977
THORNES JB PROCESS GEOMORPHOLOG 1 1979
THRIFT NJ DIFFUSING GEOGRAPHY 375 1995
TROUTMAN BM WATER RESOUR RES 28 563* 1992
VANBEMMELEN RW J GEOL 69 453 1961
VONBERTALANFFY L BRIT J PHILOS SCI 1 134 1950
WHIPPLE KX J GEOPHYSICAL RES 107 2002
WHITE HD J AM SOC INF SCI TEC 52 87 2001
WHITTEN EHT GEOLOGICAL SOC AM B 75 455 1964
WILCOCK DN GEOLOGICAL SOC AM B 86 47 1975
WILLGOOSE G WATER RESOUR RES 27 1671* 1991
WITTGENSTEIN L PHILOS INVESTIGATION 1953
When responding, please attach my original message
_______________________________________________________________________
Eugene Garfield, PhD. email: garfield at codex.cis.upenn.edu
home page: www.eugenegarfield.org
Tel: 215-243-2205 Fax 215-387-1266
President, The Scientist LLC. www.the-scientist.com
Chairman Emeritus, ISI www.isinet.com
Past President, American Society for Information Science and Technology
(ASIS&T) www.asis.org
_______________________________________________________________________
More information about the SIGMETRICS
mailing list