CITE: Noah, Sanctifying scientific peer review: Publication as a proxy for regulatory decisionmaking
Gretchen Whitney
gwhitney at UTKUX.UTCC.UTK.EDU
Wed Jul 5 18:26:39 EDT 2000
Author e-mail is probably noah at law.ufl.edu
AU Noah, L
TI Sanctifying scientific peer review: Publication as a proxy for
regulatory decisionmaking
SO UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH LAW REVIEW
LA English
DT Article
NR 318
SN 0041-9915
PU UNIV PITTSBURGH LAW REVIEW
C1 Univ Florida, Coll Law, Gainesville, FL 32611 USA.
Univ Florida, Coll Law, Gainesville, FL 32611 USA.
ID BIOMEDICAL PUBLICATION; MEDICAL JOURNALS; FRAUDULENT
PUBLICATION; PRESCRIPTION DRUGS; CITATION ANALYSIS; INGELFINGER
RULE; TOXIC TORTS; SCIENCE; LAW; DAUBERT
CR 1996, CHI KENT L REV, V71, P743
1997, FED REG, V62, P18938
1997, FED REG, V62, P18940
1997, FED REG, V62, P18943
1997, FED REG, V62, P64074
1995, FED REG, V60, P62471
1995, FED REG, V60, P62472
1994, FED REG, V59, P59820
1993, FED REG, V58, P6126
1992, FED REG, V57, P56412
1983, FED REG, V48, P26720
1983, FED REG, V48, P26733
FED REG, V62, P18939
FED REG, V62, P18940
FED REG, V60, P62472
FED REG, V57, P56412
1995, HLTH L REP BNA, V4, P1368
1996, REG TOXICOL PHARM, V24, PS191
*HOUS COMM GOV OP, 1990, 101688 HR HOUS COMM, P65
*INT COMM MED, 1988, ANN INTERN MED, V108, P260
*INT COMM MED, 1997, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V277, P934
*INT COMM MED J ED, 1988, ANN INTERN MED, V108, P258
*INT COMM MED J ED, 1997, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V277, P927
*NAT LIB MED, 1996, CUMULATED INDEX MEDI, V37, P1489
*NAT LIB MED, 1996, CUMULATED INDEX MEDI, V37, P12819
*NAT RES COUNC, 1989, BIOS LAB, P14
ABRAMSON HI, 1989, HASTINGS CONST LQ, V16, P165
ABRAMSON HI, 1989, HASTINGS CONST LQ, V16, P208
ADAMS DG, 1992, FOOD DRUG LAW J, V47, P629
ALTMAN L, 1997, NY TIMES 0416, PA1
ALTMAN LK, 1996, LANCET, V347, P1382
ALTMAN LK, 1996, LANCET, V347, P1459
ALTMAN LK, 1995, NY TIMES 0110, PC3
ALTMAN LK, 1994, NY TIMES 0314, PA1
ALTMAN LK, 1992, NY TIMES 0601, PA1
ALTMAN LK, 1991, NY TIMES 1224, PC3
AMAN AC, 1993, ADM LAW, P34
ANTMAN EM, 1992, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V268, P240
ANTMAN EM, 1992, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V268, P245
ARANSON PH, 1982, CORNELL LAW REV, V68, P1
ARANSON PH, 1982, CORNELL LAW REV, V68, P63
ASTRUE MJ, 1994, LAW CONT PROBS AUT, P75
ASTRUE MJ, 1994, LAW CONT PROBS AUT, P77
AUSTIN AD, 1990, ARIZ L REV, V32, P1
AUSTIN AD, 1990, ARIZ L REV, V32, P5
AVORN J, 1982, AM J MED, V73, P4
AVORN J, 1982, AM J MED, V73, P8
BADA JL, 1998, SCIENCE, V279, P362
BAILAR JC, 1985, NEW ENGL J MED, V312, P654
BARRETT PM, 1997, WALL ST J 0122, PA1
BAUER HH, 1992, SCI LIT MYTH SCI MET, P48
BERO LA, 1992, NEW ENGL J MED, V327, P1135
BERO LA, 1992, NEW ENGL J MED, V327, P1137
BLACK B, 1994, CARDOZO L REV, V15, P1745
BLACK B, 1995, HARVARD LAW REV, V108, P1481
BLACK B, 1994, TEX LAW REV, V72, P715
BLUMENSTYK G, 1998, CHRON HIGHER ED 0320, PA39
BLUMENSTYK G, 1998, CHRON HIGHER ED 0320, PA40
BLUMENTHAL D, 1997, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V277, P1224
BLUMENTHAL D, 1997, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V277, P1226
BONFIELD AE, 1989, STATE FEDERAL ADM LA, P451
BOWDEN CL, 1994, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V271, P918
BRANDON AN, 1995, B MED LIB ASS, V83, P174
BRANDON AN, 1995, B MED LIBR ASSOC, V83, P151
BRATTON WW, 1995, NC L REV, V73, P1861
BRATTON WW, 1995, NC L REV, V73, P1885
BRENNAN TA, 1994, NEW ENGL J MED, V331, P673
BRENT RL, 1982, PEDIATRICS, V70, P754
BRENT RL, 1982, PEDIATRICS, V70, P755
BROAD W, 1982, BETRAYERS TRUTH, P87
BRUFF HH, 1989, TEX LAW REV, V67, P441
BURACK TS, 1987, VA J NAT RESOURCES, V7, P28
BURACK TS, 1987, VA J NAT RESOURCES L, V7, P27
BURNHAM JC, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1323
BURNHAM JC, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1325
BYNUM WF, 1992, MED J MED KNOWLEDGE
CARRINGTON PD, 1996, LAW CONT PROBS SUM, P51
CARRINGTON PD, 1996, LAW CONT PROBS SUM, P64
CASS RA, 1988, MARQ L REV, V71, P449
CASS RA, 1988, MARQ L REV, V71, P497
CHAN EJ, 1995, NEW YORK U LAW REV, V70, P100
CHASE M, 1997, WALL ST J 0929, PB1
CHUBIN DE, 1990, PEERLESS SCI PEER RE, P83
COLAIANNI LA, 1993, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P156
COLAIANNI LA, 1993, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P157
COLE S, 1981, SCIENCE, V214, P881
COLE S, 1981, SCIENCE, V214, P885
COTTON P, 1993, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V270, P2775
CRAMTON RC, 1986, J LEGAL EDUC, V36, P1
CRAMTON RC, 1986, J LEGAL EDUC, V36, P8
CURFMAN GD, 1997, NEW ENGL J MED, V337, P629
DAVIS KC, 1994, ADMIN LAW TREATISE, P72
DEKANAL A, 1989, UMKC L REV, V57, P233
DEKANAL A, 1989, UMKC L REV, V57, P237
DERSIMONIAN R, 1982, NEW ENGL J MED, V306, P1332
DEYO RA, 1997, NEW ENGL J MED, V336, P1179
DIMASI JA, 1991, J CLIN PHARMACOL, V31, P205
DIMASI JA, 1991, J CLIN PHARMACOL, V31, P208
DRESSER RS, 1997, WISC LAW REV, P705
DRESSER RS, 1997, WISC LAW REV, P753
EGGEN JM, 1994, U PITT L REV, V55, P944
EGGEN JM, 1994, U PITT LAW REV, V55, P889
ELDREDGE JD, 1997, B MED LIBR ASSOC, V85, P418
ELDREDGE JD, 1997, B MED LIBR ASSOC, V85, P421
ENTERLINE P, 1996, AM J IND MED, V30, P122
ENTERLINE PE, 1996, AM J IND MED, V30, P121
EPSTEIN RA, 1994, CHI KENT L REV, V70, P87
EPSTEIN RA, 1994, CHI KENT L REV, V70, P89
FINE ME, 1982, BOSTON U LAW REV, V62, P257
FINKIN MW, 1994, LAW CONT PROBS AUT, P89
FINKIN MW, 1994, LAW CONT PROBS AUT, P114
FINUCANE T, 1987, AM J MED, V83, P811
FINUCANE T, 1987, AM J MED, V83, P812
FISHER M, 1993, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P143
FOSTER KR, 1997, JUDGING SCI SCI KNOW
FREEDMAN JO, 1976, U CHICAGO LAW REV, V43, P307
FREEDMAN JO, 1976, U CHICAGO LAW REV, V43, P333
FRIEDMAN PJ, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1416
FRIEDMAN PJ, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1419
FRIEDMAN PJ, 1992, LAW MED HLTH CARE, V20, P17
GARDNER MJ, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1355
GARFIELD E, 1986, ANN INTERN MED, V105, P313
GARFIELD E, 1972, SCIENCE, V178, P471
GARFUNKEL JM, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1369
GARFUNKEL JM, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1371
GARVEY WD, 1979, COMMUNICATION ESSENC, P69
GRADY D, 1997, NY TIMES 1230, PF6
GREEN MD, 1992, NORTHWEST U LAW REV, V86, P643
GREEN MD, 1992, NORTHWEST U LAW REV, V86, P694
HAFNER K, 1998, NY TIMES 0521, PF3
HAMILTON DP, 1990, SCIENCE, V250, P1331
HAMILTON RW, 1978, TEX LAW REV, V56, P1329
HAMILTON RW, 1978, TEX LAW REV, V56, P1386
HAMMERSCHMIDT DE, 1994, J LAB CLIN MED, V123, P795
HAMMERSCHMIDT DE, 1994, J LAB CLIN MED, V123, P799
HARNAD S, 1979, SCIENCES SEP, P18
HASHIMOTO DM, 1997, OR L REV, V76, P111
HASHIMOTO DM, 1997, OR L REV, V76, P112
HASKO JA, 1995, WISC LAW REV, P479
HAVIGHURST CC, 1994, LAW CONT PROBS AUT, P1
HAVIGHURST CC, 1994, LAW CONT PROBS AUT, P3
HILTS PJ, 1991, NY TIMES 0321, PA1
HORROBIN DF, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1438
HORROBIN DF, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1441
HORTON R, 1995, LANCET, V346, P1610
HORTON R, 1995, LANCET, V346, P1611
INGELFINFJ, 1974, AM J MED, V56, P686
JACKSON C, 1997, TAMPA TRIB 0609, P20
JASANOFF S, 1990, 5 BRANCH SCI ADVISER, P33
JASANOFF S, 1995, SCI BAR LAW SCI TECH, P95
JOHANNES L, 1996, WALL ST J 0828, PB3
KASSIRER JP, 1994, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P96
KASSIRER JP, 1994, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P97
KASSIRER JP, 1994, NEW ENGL J MED, V331, P669
KESSLER DA, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V264, P2409
KESSLER DA, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V264, P2411
KESSLER DA, 1991, NEW ENGL J MED, V325, P201
KINNEY ED, 1994, LAW CONT PROBS AUT, P47
KNOLL E, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1330
KNOLL E, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1331
KOHN A, 1986, FALSE PROPHETS FRAUD
KOLATA G, 1998, NY TIMES 0401, PA1
KOLATA G, 1997, NY TIMES 0916, PA1
KOLATA G, 1997, NY TIMES 0923, PF1
KOSHLAND DE, 1987, SCIENCE, V235, P141
KOTZIN S, 1989, B MED LIB ASS, V77, P338
KOTZIN S, 1989, B MED LIBR ASSOC, V77, P337
KRENT HJ, 1990, NORTHWEST U LAW REV, V85, P62
KRENT HJ, 1990, NORTHWEST U LAW REV, V85, P64
KRENT HJ, 1990, NORTHWEST U LAW REV, V85, P71
KRENT HJ, 1990, NORTHWEST U LAW REV, V85, P110
KRONICK DA, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1321
KURTZ H, 1991, WASHINGTON POST 0616, PA10
LABAND DN, 1994, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P147
LAWRENCE DM, 1986, INDIANA LAW J, V61, P647
LIEBMANN GW, 1975, IND LJ, V50, P660
LIEBMANN GW, 1975, INDIANA LAW J, V50, P650
LINDGREN J, 1996, CHI KENT L REV, V71, P781
LINDGREN J, 1994, U CHICAGO LAW REV, V61, P527
LINDREN J, 1996, CHI KENT L REV, V71, P786
LOCK S, 1985, DIFFICULT BALANCE ED, P39
LOCK S, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1341
LOCK S, 1989, NEW ENGL J MED, V321, P837
LOCK S, 1989, NEW ENGL J MED, V321, P838
LOWRANCE WW, 1985, MODERN SCI HUMAN VAL, P85
LUNDBERG GD, 1991, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V265, P400
LUNDBERG GD, 1989, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V262, P2003
LUNDBERG GD, 1989, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V262, P2004
MACEY JR, 1994, CARDOZO L REV, V15, P909
MACEY JR, 1994, CARDOZO L REV, V15, P913
MADDOX J, 1989, NATURE, V339, P657
MADDOX J, 1988, NATURE, V334, P287
MARSHALL E, 1994, SCIENCE, V263, P1212
MARSHALL E, 1992, SCIENCE, V257, P620
MCCUTCHEN CW, 1991, TECH REV OCT, P33
MCCUTCHEN CW, 1991, TECHNOL REV OCT, P28
MCGARITY PO, 1994, HIGH TECH LJ, V9, P1
MCLACHLAN JA, 1997, SCIENCE, V277, P462
MERRILL RA, 1996, VA LAW REV, V82, P1753
MERRILL RA, 1996, VA LAW REV, V82, P1840
MERRILL RA, 1996, VA LAW REV, V82, P1853
MONAHAN J, 1986, U PENN LAW REV, V134, P477
MONAHAN J, 1986, U PENN LAW REV, V134, P495
MURRAY GD, 1988, BRIT J SURG, V75, P664
MURRAY GD, 1988, BRIT J SURG, V75, P666
NIGG HN, 1994, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P168
NOAH L, 1997, CATHOL U LAW REV, V47, P113
NOAH L, 1995, FLA L REV, V47, P63
NOAH L, 1995, FLA L REV, V47, P107
NOAH L, 1992, FOOD DRUG LAW J, V47, P309
NOAH L, 1992, FOOD DRUG LJ, V47, P322
NOAH L, 1997, GA L REV, V32, P141
NOAH L, 1998, IN PRESS BU L REV, V78
NOAH L, 1994, J PROD TOXICS LIAB, V16, P139
NOAH L, 1994, J PRODS TOXICS LIAB, V16, P143
NOAH L, 1997, LEGAL ASPECTS FOOD A, P37
NOAH L, 1997, WISC LAW REV, P873
NOAH L, 1997, WISC LAW REV, P929
PFEIFER MP, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1420
PFEIFER MP, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1422
PINI P, 1995, LANCET, V346, P1681
PINI P, 1995, LANCET, V346, P1682
PINSKY LS, 1997, HOUS L REV, V34, P527
POOL R, 1991, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V265, P2697
POOL R, 1991, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V265, P2698
POOL R, 1988, SCIENCE, V241, P407
POSNER RA, 1995, STANFORD LAW REV, V47, P1131
POSNER RA, 1995, STANFORD LAW REV, V47, P1133
PRICE EC, 1996, FOOD DRUG LAW J, V51, P651
PRICE EC, 1996, FOOD DRUG LJ, V51, P660
PRIEST GL, 1992, U COLO L REV, V63, P725
PRIEST GL, 1992, U COLO L REV, V63, P728
PRYOR ES, 1990, HARVARD LAW REV, V103, P964
QUIRK PJ, 1981, IND INFLUENCE FEDERA, P177
RAIFORD DS, 1994, FOOD DRUG LAW J, V49, P37
RAIFORD DS, 1994, FOOD DRUG LJ, V49, P59
RANDALL T, 1991, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V266, P11
RELMAN AS, 1990, NEW ENGL J MED, V323, P56
RELMAN AS, 1989, NEW ENGL J MED, V321, P827
RELMAN AS, 1989, NEW ENGL J MED, V321, P828
RELMAN AS, 1983, NEW ENGL J MED, V308, P1219
RELMAN AS, 1983, NEW ENGL J MED, V308, P1220
RENNIE D, 1997, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V277, P1238
RENNIE D, 1994, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P91
RENNIE D, 1993, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V270, P2856
RENNIE D, 1993, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V270, P2857
RENNIE D, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1317
RENNIE D, 1989, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V261, P2543
RENNIE D, 1989, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V261, P2544
RICHARDS B, 1997, WALL ST J 0812, PB4
RICHARDS B, 1997, WALL STREET J 0723, PB1
RICHARDSON DM, 1994, J LEGAL EDUC, V44, P6
ROBBINS IP, 1988, UCLA LAW REV, V35, P911
ROBBINS IP, 1988, UCLA LAW REV, V35, P919
ROCHON PA, 1994, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P108
ROCHON PA, 1994, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P111
RULIS AM, 1993, FOOD DRUG LAW J, V48, P137
RULIS AM, 1993, FOOD DRUG LJ, V48, P138
SACKETT DL, 1979, J CHRON DIS, V32, P51
SACKETT DL, 1979, J CHRON DIS, V32, P61
SARGENTICH TO, 1987, AM U L REV, V36, P419
SAVER RS, 1992, STANFORD LAW REV, V44, P1095
SAVER RS, 1992, STANFORD LAW REV, V44, P1107
SCHLEFER J, 1990, TECH REV OCT, P5
SCHOENBROD D, 1993, POWER RESPONSIBILITY
SCHWAB L, 1991, J NATL CANCER I, V83, P602
SCHWARTZ B, 1977, NORTHWEST U LAW REV, V72, P443
SCHWARTZ B, 1977, NORTHWEST U LAW REV, V72, P445
SCHWARTZ S, 1998, NEW ENGL J MED, V338, P861
SCOTT J, 1990, LA TIMES 0324, PB3
SHARP DW, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1390
SIMES RJ, 1987, STAT MED, V6, P11
SISE CB, 1991, SAN DIEGO LAW REV, V28, P401
SKRABANEK P, 1990, FOLLIES FALLACIES ME, P40
SMITH R, 1994, BRIT MED J, V309, P143
SMITH R, 1994, BRIT MED J, V309, P144
SNODGRASS GL, 1992, B MED LIBR ASSOC, V80, P328
STELFOX HT, 1998, NEW ENGL J MED, V338, P101
STELFOX HT, 1998, NEW ENGL J MED, V338, P103
STEPHENSON J, 1997, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V278, P1389
STEWART RB, 1975, HARVARD LAW REV, V88, P1669
STEWART RB, 1975, HARVARD LAW REV, V88, P1684
STEWART WW, 1987, NATURE, V325, P207
STOLBERG SG, 1998, NY TIMES 0401, PA13
STROBOS J, 1995, FOOD DRUG LAW J, V50, P533
STROBOS J, 1995, FOOD DRUG LJ, V50, P535
SUN M, 1989, SCIENCE, V244, P910
TANOUYE E, 1998, WALL ST J 0108, PB1
TANOUYE E, 1995, WALL ST J 0831, PB1
TOBIAS C, 1995, CORNELL LAW REV, V80, P529
TOBIAS C, 1995, CORNELL LAW REV, V80, P539
VENULET J, 1982, BRIT MED J, V284, P252
VENULET J, 1982, BRIT MED J, V284, P253
WADE N, 1997, NY TIMES 1007, PB11
WAKSMAN BH, 1980, J IMMUNOL, V124, P1009
WALSH CJ, 1996, RUTGERS L REV, V48, P954
WALSH CJ, 1996, RUTGERS L REV, V48, P987
WALSH CJ, 1996, RUTGERS LAW REV, V48, P883
WALSH CJ, 1994, SETON HALL L REV, V24, P1325
WEINTRAUB M, 1992, CLIN PHARMACOL THER, V51, P642
WEISER P, 1997, SCIENCE, V277, P20
WELLER AC, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1344
WELLER AC, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1345
WHITELY WP, 1994, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P170
WHITELY WP, 1994, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V272, P173
WIGMORE JH, 1940, TREATISE ANGLOAMERIC
WILEY JS, 1986, HARVARD LAW REV, V99, P713
WILEY JS, 1986, HARVARD LAW REV, V99, P723
WILLIAMS ES, 1997, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V277, P840
WILLIAMSON JW, 1986, MED USE STATISTICS, P370
YANCEY JM, 1990, AM J SURG, V159, P533
YANCEY JM, 1990, AM J SURG, V159, P534
YANKAUER A, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1338
YANKAUER A, 1990, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V263, P1339
YONKERS KA, 1997, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V278, P983
ZIMAN J, 1968, PUBLIC KNOWLEDGE, P111
ZIMAN JM, 1978, RELIABLE KNOWLEDGE E, P130
ZUGER A, 1997, NY TIMES 1216, PB11
TC 3
BP 677
EP 717
PG 41
JI Univ. Pittsb. Law Rev.
PY 1998
PD SPR
VL 59
IS 3
GA 106PY
PI PITTSBURGH
RP Noah L
Univ Florida, Coll Law, Gainesville, FL 32611 USA.
J9 UNIV PITTSBURGH LAW REV
PA UNIV PITTSBURGH SCHOOL LAW, 3900 FORBES AVE, PITTSBURGH, PA
15260 USA
UT ISI:000075139100003
ER
--------------------------------------
(c) ISI, Reprinted with permission
Please visit their website at www.isinet.com
More information about the SIGMETRICS
mailing list