SIGMETRICS Digest - 14 Jan 2000 to 15 Jan 2000 (#2000-8)
Betsy V. Martens
bvmarten at MAILBOX.SYR.EDU
Sun Jan 16 11:30:28 EST 2000
Dear Drs. Davis and Katz,
You might also be interested in some findings of a related nature (power
laws as exemplified in a study of use of precedents in judicial opinions)
by David G. Post and Michael B. Eisen) to be published in a forthcoming
issue of The Journal of Legal Studies (special issue edited by Fred
Shapiro). A draft of the paper itself can be found at:
Betsy Van der Veer Martens
School of Information Studies
On Sun, 16 Jan 2000, Automatic digest processor wrote:
> There is one message totalling 93 lines in this issue.
> Topics of the day:
> 1. Feedback on research requested
> Date: Sat, 15 Jan 2000 12:06:05 -0500
> From: "Charles H. Davis" <davisc at INDIANA.EDU>
> Subject: Re: Feedback on research requested
> Dear Dr. Katz:
> Your communication was most welcome. I've been trying for some time to
> call power curves to the attention of the information science community.
> When I spoke with late Derek Price at an ASIS meeting in Banff in 1979, he
> told me that he had "...thrown out a number of 'outliers'."
> D.J. de S. Price, "A General Theory of Bibliometric and Other Cumulative
> Advantage Processes," JASIS 27:292-306 (1976).
> As a fellow physical scientist, I knew this was standard operating
> procedure, but it worried me as he used the plural, not the singular. It
> has since come to my attention that acknowledgments follow a power curve
> rather than an "ordinary" exponential distribution. I'm now suspicious
> about citation analysis generally and believe you or someone else should
> pursue this idea.
> See also:
> Davis, Charles H. and Blaise Cronin, "Acknowledgments and Intellectual
> Indebtedness: A Bibliometric Conjecture," Journal of the American
> Society for Information Science 44(10):590-592 (December 1993).
> All this has has implications for how scientists actually do their work:
> They may be as guilty of appeal to authority as historians. What an
> appalling thought!
> Please keep up the good work and stay in touch. Thanks to the Internet,
> we can now do such things easily. Like you, I welcome observations from
> all our colleagues.
> It's a new age.
> Charles Davis
> Charles H. Davis, Ph.D., Senior Fellow | Professor Emeritus
> School of Library and Information Science | GSLIS
> Indiana University at Bloomington | University of Illinois
> (812) 331-1322 Fax: (812) 855-6166 | Urbana-Champaign
> http://memex.lib.indiana.edu/davisc/davisc.html |
More information about the SIGMETRICS