ART:Takahashi,Impact Factor & Small Fields

Johannes Stegmann stegmann at UKBF.FU-BERLIN.DE
Fri Jul 16 08:35:48 EDT 1999


At 10:54 16.07.99 +0100, you wrote:

>
>... [Note: Careful
>consideration of the data reveals an error in the second set - the entry
>opposite 14 citations should be 6 not 5.]
>

I'm sorry, I think I made two mistakes by manual counting the numbers of
citations.
The sum of papers must be, of course, 289 in both sets (and in the second
set the sum was only 288).
I counted again, and here are the correct numbers for the second set (in
contrast to the data contained in my commenting email, it's now 49 papers
with one citation, and 7 papers with 9 citations):


No. of Papers cited              No. of Citations

     82                         0
     49                               1
     22                               2
     18                                     3
     17                               4
     19                         5
     13                                 6
     11                         7
      9                         8
      7                         9
      3                              10
      4                        11
      1                        12
      6                        13
      5                        14
      1                        15
      4                        16
      2                        17
      2                        18
      4                        19
      2                        20
      3                        23
      2                        25
      1                        26
      1                        33
      1                        35


I hope, I did not miscount again; for that case you can find below the
original data (for the second set) as retrieved from the DIMDI computer:

No. of citations
    received           Cited paper

      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
       35    2.67  SIMEONOVA PP,1995,V12,P676
!*****************************
       33    2.52  TIMBLIN CR,1995,V55,P2723     !***************************
       26    1.98  WILKINSON P,1995,V345,P1074   !**********************
       25    1.91  QUINLAN TR,1994,V150,P200     !*********************
       25    1.91  THOMAS G,1994,V11,P707        !*********************
       23    1.75  BOYLAN AM,1995,V96,P1987      !*******************
       23    1.75  SCHAPIRA RM,1994,V10,P573     !*******************
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
       23    1.75  TAKEUCHI T,1994,V15,P635      !*******************
       20    1.52  LASKY JA,1995,V12,P162        !*****************
       20    1.52  LUND LG,1994,V51,P200         !*****************
       19    1.45  ADACHI S,1994,V15,P753        !****************
       19    1.45  DEMENT JM,1994,V26,P431       !****************
       19    1.45  KARN CM,1994,V73,P74          !****************
       19    1.45  PERDUE TD,1994,V42,P1061      !****************
       18    1.37  HART GA,1994,V15,P971         !***************
       18    1.37  HIRVONEN A,1995,V55,P2981     !***************
       17    1.30  GHIO AJ,1994,V311,P13         !**************
       17    1.30  WANG X,1995,V4,P543           !**************
       16    1.22  HARDY JA,1995,V16,P319        !*************
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
       16    1.22  MAGNANI C,1995,V52,P362       !*************
       16    1.22  MUSSELMAN RP,1994,V102,P139   !*************
       16    1.22  SPIRTAS R,1994,V51,P804       !*************
       15    1.14  DRISCOLL KE,1995,V46,P155     !************
       14    1.07  CHAO CC,1994,V308,P64         !************
       14    1.07  CHURG A,1994,V150,P663        !************
       14    1.07  KARJALAINEN A,1994,V20,P243   !************
       14    1.07  VAINIO H,1994,V20,P235        !************
       14    1.07  WACHOLDER S,1994,V140,P303    !************
       13    0.99  BECKLAKE MR,1994,V150,P1488   !***********
       13    0.99  CHAO CC,1994,V314,P384        !***********
       13    0.99  KINNULA VL,1994,V16,P169      !***********
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
       13    0.99  KUWAHARA M,1994,V10,P167      !***********
       13    0.99  MOYER VD,1994,V102,P131       !***********
       13    0.99  QUINLAN TR,1994,V102,P107     !***********
       12    0.91  FAUX SP,1994,V15,P1749        !**********
       11    0.84  GRIFFITH DE,1994,V10,P245     !*********
       11    0.84  MAHMOOD N,1994,V200,P687      !*********
       11    0.84  MOLLO F,1995,V60,P289         !*********
       11    0.84  UEKI A,1994,V82,P332          !*********
       10    0.76  BELLMANN B,1994,V102,P185     !********
       10    0.76  CHURG A,1994,V38,P625         !********
       10    0.76  DOPP E,1995,V103,P268         !********
        9    0.69  CORSINI E,1994,V11,P531       !*******
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        9    0.69  GENNARO V,1994,V20,P213       !*******
        9    0.69  KARJALAINEN A,1994,V51,P456   !*******
        9    0.69  NUORVA K,1994,V150,P528       !*******
        9    0.69  PAIRON JC,1994,V51,P244       !*******
        9    0.69  QUINLAN TR,1995,V147,P728     !*******
        9    0.69  WALKER C,1995,V55,P530        !*******
        8    0.61  AULT JG,1995,V55,P792         !*******
        8    0.61  BERNSTEIN DM,1994,V102,P15    !*******
        8    0.61  DONG HY,1995,V331,P197        !*******
        8    0.61  IMBERNON E,1995,V28,P339      !*******
        8    0.61  KAMP DW,1995,V268,PL471       !*******
        8    0.61  MOSSMAN BT,1994,V38,P617      !*******
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        8    0.61  MURAI Y,1995,V50,P19          !*******
        8    0.61  SCHWARTZ DA,1994,V150,P1243   !*******
        8    0.61  VOISIN C,1995,V107,P477       !*******
        7    0.53  BARRETT JC,1994,V102,P19      !******
        7    0.53  CASE BW,1994,V38,P503         !******
        7    0.53  CHURG A,1995,V151,P1409       !******
        7    0.53  GERWIN BI,1994,V11,P507       !******
        7    0.53  JAKOBSSON K,1994,V51,P95      !******
        7    0.53  KAMP DW,1994,V266,PL84        !******
        7    0.53  KARJALAINEN A,1994,V51,P212   !******
        7    0.53  KEELING B,1994,V10,P683       !******
        7    0.53  KINNULA VL,1995,V18,P391      !******
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        7    0.53  MEURMAN LO,1994,V51,P421      !******
        7    0.53  PELIN K,1995,V25,P118         !******
        6    0.46  DUFRESNE A,1995,V27,P581      !*****
        6    0.46  GHIO AJ,1994,V315,P219        !*****
        6    0.46  HEI TK,1995,V16,P1573         !*****
        6    0.46  HILL IM,1995,V52,P92          !*****
        6    0.46  HOMA DM,1994,V139,P1210       !*****
        6    0.46  ISHIZAKI T,1994,V66,P208      !*****
        6    0.46  ISRABIAN VA,1994,V267,PL518   !*****
        6    0.46  PELIN K,1995,V334,P225        !*****
        6    0.46  PIGG BJ,1994,V38,P453         !*****
        6    0.46  SEKHON H,1995,V76,P411        !*****
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        6    0.46  THOMAS G,1994,V725,P207       !*****
        6    0.46  YEGLES M,1995,V16,P2751       !*****
        6    0.46  ZITTING AJ,1995,V21,P470      !*****
        5    0.38  ABRAHAM JL,1994,V26,P839      !****
        5    0.38  BERMAN DW,1995,V15,P181       !****
        5    0.38  BROWN DP,1994,V36,P882        !****
        5    0.38  DEMENT JM,1994,V38,P525       !****
        5    0.38  DONALDSON K,1995,V47,P207     !****
        5    0.38  GIAROLI C,1994,V66,P7         !****
        5    0.38  JAKOBSSON K,1994,V51,P812     !****
        5    0.38  JAKOBSSON K,1995,V52,P20      !****
        5    0.38  KUWAHARA M,1995,V76,P163      !****
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        5    0.38  MONSO E,1995,V50,P305         !****
        5    0.38  MUSCAT JE,1995,V27,P257       !****
        5    0.38  NAKADATE T,1995,V52,P368      !****
        5    0.38  ORLOWSKI E,1994,V26,P349      !****
        5    0.38  POTT F,1994,V38,P589          !****
        5    0.38  ROGGLI VL,1994,V26,P835       !****
        5    0.38  SHIH JF,1994,V105,P1370       !****
        5    0.38  SREBRO SH,1995,V8,P614        !****
        5    0.38  TESCHLER H,1994,V149,P641     !****
        5    0.38  TOSSAVAINEN A,1994,V102,P253  !****
        4    0.30  ANDERSSON E,1995,V27,P577     !***
        4    0.30  BIGNON J,1995,V39,P89         !***
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        4    0.30  DEMERS RY,1994,V36,P1027      !***
        4    0.30  FAUX SP,1994,V311,P209        !***
        4    0.30  GOLDBERG P,1995,V43,P444      !***
        4    0.30  GOVERNA M,1995,V11,P237       !***
        4    0.30  HUNCHAREK M,1994,V12,P214     !***
        4    0.30  KARJALAINEN A,1994,V26,P645   !***
        4    0.30  LEE RJ,1995,V119,P528         !***
        4    0.30  LI XY,1994,V64,P181           !***
        4    0.30  LJUNGMAN AG,1994,V51,P777     !***
        4    0.30  LONGO WE,1995,V55,P2232       !***
        4    0.30  NICHOLSON WJ,1995,V86,P393    !***
        4    0.30  PAIRON JC,1994,V25,P793       !***
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        4    0.30  SAKAI K,1994,V73,P1825        !***
        4    0.30  TAKAHASHI K,1994,V51,P461     !***
        4    0.30  WHYSNER J,1994,V23,P119       !***
        3    0.23  ADAMSON IY,1994,V10,P253      !**
        3    0.23  BERRY G,1994,V38,P539         !**
        3    0.23  BOTH K,1994,V59,P538          !**
        3    0.23  DIXON D,1995,V14,P205         !**
        3    0.23  GIBBS AR,1994,V102,P261       !**
        3    0.23  GUN RT,1995,V162,P429         !**
        3    0.23  HURBANKOVA M,1994,V102,P201   !**
        3    0.23  KAMP DW,1995,V23,P689         !**
        3    0.23  LEMEN RA,1994,V10,P59         !**
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        3    0.23  LIPPMANN M,1994,V38,P459      !**
        3    0.23  LIPPMANN M,1994,V51,P793      !**
        3    0.23  LUO SQ,1995,V8,P54            !**
        3    0.23  MARCZYNSKI B,1994,V13,P3      !**
        3    0.23  MORGAN A,1995,V39,P747        !**
        3    0.23  NERI S,1994,V51,P239          !**
        3    0.23  ROSENTHAL GJ,1994,V153,P3237  !**
        3    0.23  STURM W,1994,V72,P317         !**
        3    0.23  WEISS W,1995,V37,P1364        !**
        2    0.15  ASLAM M,1995,V15,P27          !**
        2    0.15  BOTH K,1995,V26,P67           !**
        2    0.15  CHAILLEUX E,1995,V12,P353     !**
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        2    0.15  COIN PG,1994,V102,P197        !**
        2    0.15  GROSS TJ,1994,V266,PL287      !**
        2    0.15  JANSSEN YM,1995,V15,P2085     !**
        2    0.15  JANSSEN YM,1995,V55,P2085     !**
        2    0.15  LANGER AM,1994,V102,P235      !**
        2    0.15  LIDDELL D,1994,V38,P519       !**
        2    0.15  LU J,1994,V320,P253           !**
        2    0.15  MAGNANI C,1995,V19,P338       !**
        2    0.15  MUSK AW,1995,V19,P520         !**
        2    0.15  NOLAN RP,1994,V102,P245       !**
        2    0.15  RIBAK J,1995,V23,P35          !**
        2    0.15  ROGERS A,1995,V21,P259        !**
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        2    0.15  ROGGLI VL,1995,V39,P363       !**
        2    0.15  RUOTSALAINEN M,1995,V78,P195  !**
        2    0.15  SARIC M,1994,V22,P293         !**
        2    0.15  SCHLECHT PC,1995,V56,P480     !**
        2    0.15  SREBRO SH,1994,V26,P809       !**
        2    0.15  VALKILA EH,1995,V28,P363      !**
        2    0.15  WEILL H,1994,V38,P533         !**
        1    0.08  AHMAD I,1995,V33,P209         !*
        1    0.08  ANDRION A,1994,V25,P617       !*
        1    0.08  ARIF JM,1994,V102,P181        !*
        1    0.08  BROWN DP,1994,V38,P882        !*
        1    0.08  CAMBELOVA M,1994,V51,P343     !*
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        1    0.08  CHAILLEUX E,1995,V4,P353      !*
        1    0.08  CORN M,1994,V4,P495           !*
        1    0.08  CROSIGNANI P,1995,V27,P573    !*
        1    0.08  DODSON RF,1995,V27,P207       !*
        1    0.08  DOGRA S,1995,V33,P131         !*
        1    0.08  DONALDSON K,1994,V72,P299     !*
        1    0.08  DONALDSON K,1995,V177,P303    !*
        1    0.08  DOSSING M,1994,V26,P755       !*
        1    0.08  EGILMAN DS,1995,V25,P667      !*
        1    0.08  ERDOGDU G,1994,V50,P785       !*
        1    0.08  FALCHI M,1994,V30,P139        !*
        1    0.08  GIBBS AR,1994,V104,P261       !*
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        1    0.08  GIBBS GW,1994,V38,P477        !*
        1    0.08  HILLERDAL G,1994,V38,P561     !*
        1    0.08  HUGHES JM,1994,V38,P555       !*
        1    0.08  HUUSKONEN MS,1995,V86,P426    !*
        1    0.08  JANSSEN YM,1995,V92,P8458     !*
        1    0.08  KAMP DW,1994,V10,PL84         !*
        1    0.08  KAMP DW,1995,V12,PL471        !*
        1    0.08  KARN CM,1994,V731,P74         !*
        1    0.08  KASHANSKII SV,1995,V5,P19     !*
        1    0.08  LANGE JH,1995,V55,P325        !*
        1    0.08  LANGER AM,1994,V38,P427       !*
        1    0.08  LEE MM,1994,V1226,P151        !*
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        1    0.08  LEVIN JL,1995,V50,P462        !*
        1    0.08  MAGNANI C,1994,V85,P157       !*
        1    0.08  MURAI Y,1994,V49,P67          !*
        1    0.08  MUSSELMAN RP,1994,V105,P139   !*
        1    0.08  NEVITT C,1994,V26,P821        !*
        1    0.08  NUORVA K,1994,V159,P528       !*
        1    0.08  NYBERG P,1994,V97,P334        !*
        1    0.08  PERDUE TD,1994,V24,P1061      !*
        1    0.08  PINTO C,1995,V86,P484         !*
        1    0.08  RICHTER ED,1995,V86,P449      !*
        1    0.08  ROGGLI VL,1994,V38,P502       !*
        1    0.08  SCHNEIDER J,1995,V196,P495    !*
      OCC     %    TERM
+-----------------------------
        1    0.08  SEKHON H,1995,V75,P411        !*
        1    0.08  SHIH JF,1994,V10,P1370        !*
        1    0.08  SOODAEVA SK,1994,V118,P145    !*
        1    0.08  SOODAEVA SK,1994,V130,P145    !*
        1    0.08  STURM W,1995,V47,P173         !*
        1    0.08  VOISIN C,1994,V106,P974       !*
        1    0.08  WILLIAMS V,1995,V28,P489      !*
        1    0.08  WILSON R,1994,V20,P161        !*
***END OF SHOW***


Regards,

Johannes Stegmann

-------------------------------------------------------
Dr. Johannes Stegmann      Univ. Hospital Benjamin Franklin
Free University Berlin     Medical Library
stegmann at ukbf.fu-berlin.de Hindenburgdamm 30
Tel.: +49 30 8445 2035     D-12200 Berlin
Fax:  +49 30 8445 4454     Germany
  Homepage:  http://www.medizin.fu-berlin.de/medbib/home.html



More information about the SIGMETRICS mailing list