[Asis-standards] Upcoming February votes
TIMOTHY DICKEY
tdickey1 at kent.edu
Fri Jan 27 15:43:06 EST 2017
Good afternoon, Mark,
On the first group:
1) Z39.87 YES, reafirm
2) Z39.43 YES, reaffirm
3) On Z39.84 this actually was a bit of a surprise, but if I am reading
this all correctly, voting YES we approve the withdrawal means there is
still a data transfer standard, it is just a single international one. If
this is correct, YES!
All best,
timothy
Timothy J. Dickey, Ph.D., MLIS.
tdickey1 at kent.edu
(614) 785-1632
On Tue, Jan 24, 2017 at 2:12 PM, Mark Needleman <needleman_mark at yahoo.com>
wrote:
> Folks
>
> Here are some upcoming votes - sorry about the short notice on some of
> them - ill be sending out some more in a few days. All relevant documents
> attached
>
>
> Mark
>
> 1) Review of ANSI/NISO Z39.87-2006 (R2011) Data Dictionary - Technical
> Metadata for Digital Still Images
>
>
> Do you approve the reaffirmation of Z39.87?
> This ballot is for the periodic review of the published standard ANSI/NISO
> Z39.87-2006 (R2011) Data Dictionary - Technical Metadata for Digital Still
> Images. This standard was last reviewed and reaffirmed in 2011.
>
> In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are accompanied by
> a recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. NISO's Content
> and Collection Management Topic Committee recommends to REAFFIRM the
> standard.
>
> Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options:
>
> YES - Approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments optional)
>
> NO - Do not approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments required)
>
> ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the voting
> pool volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
>
> Due 2/4/2017
>
>
> 2) Review of ANSI/NISO Z39.43-1993 (R2011) Standard Address Number (SAN)
> for the Publishing Industry
>
> Do you approve the reaffirmation of Z39.43?
>
> This ballot is for the periodic review of the published standard ANSI/NISO
> Z39.43-1993 (R2011) Standard Address Number (SAN) for the Publishing
> Industry. This standard was last reviewed and reaffirmed in 2011.
>
> In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are accompanied by
> a recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. NISO's Content
> and Collection Management Topic Committee recommends to REAFFIRM the
> standard.
>
> Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options:
>
> YES - Approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments optional)
>
> NO - Do not approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments required)
>
> ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the voting
> pool volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
>
> Due 2/4/2017
>
>
> 3) Review of / Withdraw ANSI/NISO Z39.84-2005 (R2010) Syntax for the
> Digital Object Identifier
>
> Should ANSI/NISO Z39.84 be withdrawn?
>
> In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are accompanied by
> a recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. The Content and
> Collections Management Topic Committee recommends a vote to WITHDRAW the
> standard. ISO 26324:2012 Information and documentation -- Digital object
> identifier system is now available. Experts have noted that material
> covered in Z39.84 is addressed in the ISO standard, sometimes in more
> up-to-date ways. It would be better to coalesce efforts to keep the
> International standard updated rather than the ANSI/NISO one.
>
> Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options, in
> response to the CCM recommended action of withdraw:
>
> YES - Approve the withdrawal of Z39.84 (comments optional)
>
> NO - Do not approve the withdrawal of Z39.84 (comments required)
>
> ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the voting
> pool volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
>
> NOTES: This recommendation/ballot is not as to whether the ISO standard
> should be reaffirmed/revised/withdrawn, but rather whether NISO should
> continue to maintain Z39.84 as a distinct standard. If Z39.84 is withdrawn
> as a NISO standard, ISO 26324:2012 will continue to be accessible at ISO.
> NISO participates in ISO discussions through TC46, so Voting Members will
> continue to have a voice in any modifications or updates, if any take place.
>
> Due 2/4/2017
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Mark
>
> 1) Review of ANSI/NISO Z39.87-2006 (R2011) Data Dictionary - Technical
> Metadata
> for Digital Still Images
>
> Do you approve the reaffirmation of Z39.87?
> This ballot is for the periodic review of the published standard
> ANSI/NISO
> Z39.87-2006 (R2011) Data Dictionary - Technical Metadata for Digital
> Still
> Images. This standard was last reviewed and reaffirmed in 2011.
> In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are accompanied
> by a
> recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. NISO's
> Content and
> Collection Management Topic Committee recommends to REAFFIRM the
> standard.
>
> Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options:
> YES - Approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments optional)
> NO - Do not approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments
> required)
> ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the voting
> pool
> volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
>
> Due 2/4/2017
>
> 2) Review of ANSI/NISO Z39.43-1993 (R2011) Standard Address Number (SAN)
> for
> the Publishing Industry
>
> Do you approve the reaffirmation of Z39.43?
> This ballot is for the periodic review of the published standard
> ANSI/NISO
> Z39.43-1993 (R2011) Standard Address Number (SAN) for the Publishing
> Industry. This standard was last reviewed and reaffirmed in 2011.
> In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are accompanied
> by a
> recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. NISO's
> Content and
> Collection Management Topic Committee recommends to REAFFIRM the
> standard.
> Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options:
> YES - Approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments optional)
> NO - Do not approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments
> required)
> ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the voting
> pool
> volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
> Due 2/4/2017
>
> 3) Review of / Withdraw ANSI/NISO Z39.84-2005 (R2010) Syntax for the
> Digital
> Object Identifier
>
> Should ANSI/NISO Z39.84 be withdrawn?
> In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are accompanied
> by a
> recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. The Content
> and
> Collections Management Topic Committee recommends a vote to WITHDRAW the
> standard. ISO 26324:2012 Information and documentation -- Digital object
> identifier system is now available. Experts have noted that material
> covered
> in Z39.84 is addressed in the ISO standard, sometimes in more up-to-date
> ways. It would be better to coalesce efforts to keep the International
> standard updated rather than the ANSI/NISO one.
> Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options, in
> response to the CCM recommended action of withdraw:
> YES - Approve the withdrawal of Z39.84 (comments optional)
> NO - Do not approve the withdrawal of Z39.84 (comments required)
> ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the voting
> pool
> volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
> NOTES: This recommendation/ballot is not as to whether the ISO standard
> should be reaffirmed/revised/withdrawn, but rather whether NISO should
> continue to maintain Z39.84 as a distinct standard. If Z39.84 is
> withdrawn
> as a NISO standard, ISO 26324:2012 will continue to be accessible at
> ISO.
> NISO participates in ISO discussions through TC46, so Voting Members
> will
> continue to have a voice in any modifications or updates, if any take
> place.
> Due 2/4/2017
>
> _______________________________________________
> Asis-standards mailing list
> Asis-standards at asis.org
> http://mail.asis.org/mailman/listinfo/asis-standards
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
Good afternoon, Mark,
On the first group:
1) Z39.87 YES, reafirm
2) Z39.43 YES, reaffirm
3) On Z39.84 this actually was a bit of a surprise, but if I am reading this
all correctly, voting YES we approve the withdrawal means there is still a
data transfer standard, it is just a single international one. If this is
correct, YES!
All best,
timothy
Timothy J. Dickey, Ph.D., MLIS.
[1]tdickey1 at kent.edu
(614) 785-1632
On Tue, Jan 24, 2017 at 2:12 PM, Mark Needleman
<[2]needleman_mark at yahoo.com> wrote:
Folks
Here are some upcoming votes - sorry about the short notice on some of
them - ill be sending out some more in a few days. All relevant documents
attached
Mark
1) Review of ANSI/NISO Z39.87-2006 (R2011) Data Dictionary - Technical
Metadata for Digital Still Images
Do you approve the reaffirmation of Z39.87?
This ballot is for the periodic review of the published standard ANSI/NISO
Z39.87-2006 (R2011) Data Dictionary - Technical Metadata for Digital Still
Images. This standard was last reviewed and reaffirmed in 2011.
In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are accompanied by
a recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. NISO's Content
and Collection Management Topic Committee recommends to REAFFIRM the
standard.
Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options:
YES - Approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments optional)
NO - Do not approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments required)
ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the voting
pool volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
Due 2/4/2017
2) Review of ANSI/NISO Z39.43-1993 (R2011) Standard Address Number (SAN)
for the Publishing Industry
Do you approve the reaffirmation of Z39.43?
This ballot is for the periodic review of the published standard ANSI/NISO
Z39.43-1993 (R2011) Standard Address Number (SAN) for the Publishing
Industry. This standard was last reviewed and reaffirmed in 2011.
In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are accompanied by
a recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. NISO's Content
and Collection Management Topic Committee recommends to REAFFIRM the
standard.
Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options:
YES - Approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments optional)
NO - Do not approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments required)
ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the voting
pool volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
Due 2/4/2017
3) Review of / Withdraw ANSI/NISO Z39.84-2005 (R2010) Syntax for the
Digital Object Identifier
Should ANSI/NISO Z39.84 be withdrawn?
In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are accompanied by
a recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. The Content
and Collections Management Topic Committee recommends a vote to WITHDRAW
the standard. ISO 26324:2012 Information and documentation -- Digital
object identifier system is now available. Experts have noted that
material covered in Z39.84 is addressed in the ISO standard, sometimes in
more up-to-date ways. It would be better to coalesce efforts to keep the
International standard updated rather than the ANSI/NISO one.
 Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options, in
response to the CCM recommended action of withdraw:
YES - Approve the withdrawal of Z39.84 (comments optional)
NO - Do not approve the withdrawal of Z39.84 (comments required)
ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the voting
pool volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
NOTES: This recommendation/ballot is not as to whether the ISO standard
should be reaffirmed/revised/withdrawn, but rather whether NISO should
continue to maintain Z39.84 as a distinct standard. If Z39.84 is withdrawn
as a NISO standard, ISO 26324:2012 will continue to be accessible at ISO.
NISO participates in ISO discussions through TC46, so Voting Members will
continue to have a voice in any modifications or updates, if any take
place.
Due 2/4/2017
  Mark
1) Review of ANSI/NISO Z39.87-2006 (R2011) Data Dictionary - Technical
Metadata
for Digital Still Images
  Do you approve the reaffirmation of Z39.87?
  This ballot is for the periodic review of the published standard
ANSI/NISO
  Z39.87-2006 (R2011) Data Dictionary - Technical Metadata for Digital
Still
  Images. This standard was last reviewed and reaffirmed in 2011.
  In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are
accompanied by a
  recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. NISO's
Content and
  Collection Management Topic Committee recommends to REAFFIRM the
standard.
  Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options:
  YES - Approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments optional)
  NO - Do not approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments
required)
  ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the
voting pool
  volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
  Due 2/4/2017
2) Review of ANSI/NISO Z39.43-1993 (R2011) Standard Address Number (SAN)
for
the Publishing Industry
  Do you approve the reaffirmation of Z39.43?
  This ballot is for the periodic review of the published standard
ANSI/NISO
  Z39.43-1993 (R2011) Standard Address Number (SAN) for the
Publishing
  Industry. This standard was last reviewed and reaffirmed in 2011.
  In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are
accompanied by a
  recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. NISO's
Content and
  Collection Management Topic Committee recommends to REAFFIRM the
standard.
  Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options:
  YES - Approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments optional)
  NO - Do not approve the Reaffirmation of the standard (comments
required)
  ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the
voting pool
  volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
  Due 2/4/2017
3) Review of / Withdraw ANSI/NISO Z39.84-2005 (R2010) Syntax for the
Digital
Object Identifier
  Should ANSI/NISO Z39.84 be withdrawn?
  In accordance with NISO procedures, all review ballots are
accompanied by a
  recommendation from the responsible leadership committee. The Content
and
  Collections Management Topic Committee recommends a vote to WITHDRAW
the
  standard. ISO 26324:2012 Information and documentation -- Digital
object
  identifier system is now available. Experts have noted that material
covered
  in Z39.84 is addressed in the ISO standard, sometimes in more
up-to-date
  ways. It would be better to coalesce efforts to keep the
International
  standard updated rather than the ANSI/NISO one.
  Please cast your ballot with one of the following voting options,
in
  response to the CCM recommended action of withdraw:
  YES - Approve the withdrawal of Z39.84 (comments optional)
  NO - Do not approve the withdrawal of Z39.84 (comments required)
  ABSTAIN from voting (comments are required since members of the
voting pool
  volunteered to join, so an abstention vote requires explanation)
  NOTES: This recommendation/ballot is not as to whether the ISO
standard
  should be reaffirmed/revised/withdrawn, but rather whether NISO
should
  continue to maintain Z39.84 as a distinct standard. If Z39.84 is
withdrawn
  as a NISO standard, ISO 26324:2012 will continue to be accessible at
ISO.
  NISO participates in ISO discussions through TC46, so Voting Members
will
  continue to have a voice in any modifications or updates, if any
take
  place.
  Due 2/4/2017
_______________________________________________
Asis-standards mailing list
[3]Asis-standards at asis.org
[4]http://mail.asis.org/mailman/listinfo/asis-standards
References
1. mailto:tdickey1 at kent.edu
2. mailto:needleman_mark at yahoo.com
3. mailto:Asis-standards at asis.org
4. http://mail.asis.org/mailman/listinfo/asis-standards
More information about the Asis-standards
mailing list