[Asis-standards] More votes part2

[Mark Needleman-UF]

2nd note on upcoming votes:  - these are to keep the current ISO ILL
standard active until the new one gets published and implemented

 

1)  ISO/FDIS 10160, Interlibrary Loan Application Service Definition

Do you approve ISO/FDIS 10160 for publication?

 

This is the first of three ballots that make up the standard Information and
documentation -- Open Systems Interconnection -- Interlibrary Loan
Application.

This ballot is for ISO/FDIS 10160, Interlibrary Loan Application Service
Definition, which defines the required services for interlibrary loan.

In the systematic review of these standards conducted in 2013, the members
voted to Confirm them. The standard is being replaced with a new ILL
standard (the forthcoming ISO 18626, Information and documentation --
Interlibrary Loan Transactions) and the agreement was that this existing
series would be maintained for the time being, while it was still in use.
Following the systematic review, the former maintenance agency pointed out
some minor issues that could impact the standards' ongoing usage. These
minor changes have been incorporated into the current draft standard at
ballot, which has been issued immediately at the FDIS stage for approval. If
approved, it will go directly to publication.

Both the draft standard and a document describing the changes that were made
are available from the ballot webpage and the link in the announcement
email. Some corresponding changes to graphics were also made to match the
textual changes that are noted in the change document.

NISO is recommending that you vote YES on this ballot.

Your voting options are:
YES - approve the draft standard to go directly to publication (comments
optional)
NO - do not approve the standard (comments required)
ABSTAIN from voting (comments optional)

 

Comments and a recommendation for a vote needed by 6/19

 


2)  ISO/FDIS 10161-1, Interlibrary Loan Application Protocol Specification
-- Part 1: Protocol specification


Do you approve ISO/FDIS 10161-1 for publication?


 


This ballot is for ISO/FDIS 10161-1, Interlibrary Loan Application Protocol
Specification -- Part 1: Protocol specification, which provides a protocol
utilizing the services defined in ISO 10160.

In the systematic review of these standards conducted in 2013, the members
voted to Confirm them. The standard is being replaced with a new ILL
standard (the forthcoming ISO 18626, Information and documentation --
Interlibrary Loan Transactions) and the agreement was that this existing
series would be maintained for the time being, while it was still in use.
Following the systematic review, the former maintenance agency pointed out
some minor issues that could impact the standards' ongoing usage. These
minor changes have been incorporated into the current draft standard at
ballot, which has been issued immediately at the FDIS stage for approval. If
approved, it will go directly to publication.

Both the draft standard and a document describing the changes that were made
are available from the ballot webpage and the link in the announcement
email. Some corresponding changes to graphics were also made to match the
textual changes that are noted in the change document.

NISO is recommending that you vote YES on this ballot.

Your voting options are:
YES - approve the draft standard to go directly to publication (comments
optional)
NO - do not approve the standard (comments required)
ABSTAIN from voting (comments optional)


 


Comments and a recommendation for a vote needed by 6/19


 


3)   ISO/FDIS 10161-2, Interlibrary Loan Application Protocol Specification
-- Part 2: Protocol implementation conformance statement (PICS) proforma
Do you approve ISO/FDIS 10161-2 for publication?


This ballot is for ISO/FDIS 10161-2, Interlibrary Loan Application Protocol
Specification -- Part 2: Protocol implementation conformance statement
(PICS) proforma, which provides a template for indicating conformance to
some or all requirements of the protocol (10161-1).

In the systematic review of these standards conducted in 2013, the members
voted to Confirm them. The standard is being replaced with a new ILL
standard (the forthcoming ISO 18626, Information and documentation --
Interlibrary Loan Transactions) and the agreement was that this existing
series would be maintained for the time being, while it was still in use.
Following the systematic review, the former maintenance agency pointed out
some minor issues that could impact the standards' ongoing usage. These
minor changes have been incorporated into the current draft standard at
ballot, which has been issued immediately at the FDIS stage for approval. If
approved, it will go directly to publication.

Both the draft standard and a document describing the changes that were made
are available from the ballot webpage and the link in the announcement
email. Some corresponding changes to graphics were also made to match the
textual changes that are noted in the change document.

NISO is recommending that you vote YES on this ballot.
Your voting options are:
YES - approve the draft standard to go directly to publication (comments
optional)
NO - do not approve the standard (comments required)
ABSTAIN from voting (comments optional)


 


Comments and a recommendation for a vote needed by 6/19 - All relevant
documents attached - Note that NISO is recommending a YES vote on these but
we are under no obligation to do so. 


Since I was involved with the development of these I would like some
independent views on how we should vote


 


mark


 






-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: ISO_FDIS_10160_(E).pdf
Type: application/pdf
Size: 3257492 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://mail.asis.org/pipermail/asis-standards/attachments/20140602/8d7493f7/attachment-0003.pdf>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: ISO_FDIS_10161-2_(E).pdf
Type: application/pdf
Size: 573464 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://mail.asis.org/pipermail/asis-standards/attachments/20140602/8d7493f7/attachment-0004.pdf>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: N890_A_summary_of_minor_revisions_to_be_made_to_old_ILL_standards.pdf
Type: application/pdf
Size: 34341 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://mail.asis.org/pipermail/asis-standards/attachments/20140602/8d7493f7/attachment-0005.pdf>