[Asis-standards] WG Responses to Comments on ISO/DIS 18626, Interlibrary Loan Transactions

[Mark Needleman-UF]

Folks

 

Here are the comments and replies to all the comments sent by ISO members to
the editors of the new ISO ILL standard - as you can see our comments were
not accepted - since Im technically a member of this committee im a little
annoyed

 

mark 

 

From: Cynthia Hodgson [mailto:hodgsonca at verizon.net] 
Sent: Thursday, January 02, 2014 10:44 AM
To: Nancy E Kraft; 'Brenda Bailey-Hainer'; 'Marjorie Hlava'; Mark Needleman;
Peter Murray
Subject: WG Responses to Comments on ISO/DIS 18626, Interlibrary Loan
Transactions

 

As US TC46 TAG members who provided comments to the ballot on ISO/DIS 18626,
Information and documentation - Interlibrary Loan Transactions
(http://www.niso.org/apps/org/workgroup/tc46ballots/ballot.php?id=486), I
thought you might be interested in the document listed below with the
Working Group responses to all the ballot comments received. Another
comments document was received from Jisc (a liaison, not a voting member)
and these are not included in the document below (see separate link); I
assume they are still being reviewed. Based on these responses, another FDIS
ballot should be required before the standard can be issued.

 

Comments and responses to ISO/DIS 18626:
http://www.niso.org/apps/org/workgroup/tc46sc4interest/download.php/12032/N9
00_Comments_DIS_18626_and_observations_.pdf

Jisc comments document:

http://www.niso.org/apps/org/workgroup/tc46sc4interest/download.php/12027/N8
95_JISC_comments_ISODIS_18626.pdf

Regards,

 

Cynthia Hodgson

Technical Editor / Consultant

National Information Standards Organization

hodgsonca at verizon.net

301-654-2512